ColorlessTrees
Stuck
- Jan 4, 2022
- 304
@webb&flow Always why I put the scare quotes when I'm dealing with mindsets I don't necessarily agree with. Strictly to them it's how they rationalize things, but their logic is also very informed by emotional desire to be percieved as objective; humans will never really be free of bias, especially when it comes to abstracts and beliefs, imo! It means a lot to me that you enjoy my rather indulgent ramblings here however. I probably put too much thought into them, but threads are sometimes good prompts for nailing down my thoughts on things.
I wrote a bit more about the misogyny & validation points so I'll just spoiler em for clarity of reading.
This is super circular and rambly but you get the gist.
I wrote a bit more about the misogyny & validation points so I'll just spoiler em for clarity of reading.
It's tricky because it's always been a problem. I think if anything in recent years people speak out about it more, but it's unfortunate how many predators have roamed free for far too long on account of their 'popularity' while others get banned for miscommunication or seemingly trivial things. It's unsurprising though considering the ties to incel culture, that "freedom of speech" of a particular caliber is so protected. I understand modding a forum like this is a herculean task, so I'm not trying to make any jabs at management, but I frankly do find the vibe a bit shady at times. And I'll leave it at that, this topic.
On one hand I understand; many here are extremely lonely and have no support system coupled with self esteem in the gutters. Seeking community and validation is intrinsic human behavior, but when you get into insular spaces where no one is allowed to give more than the canned 'I hope you find peace' and 'suffering isn't a competition' crap, it does get tiring. People are on the defensive at all times, or want to be validated in their self destruction. For example, I once gave a lengthy reply to a person asking how to "develop anorexia" and as someone whose life has been ruined by EDs of all flavours, that pissed me off so much. So I gave practical and empathetic advice on how to lose weight in a healthy way, as well as a cautionary tale from experience. Naturally it goes ignored for the people goading them on or redirecting them to ana bootcamps.. I should've known not to waste my time.
)
It's just one example, but people come here acting as if because it's a site for information on suicide, that somehow equals to always encouraging horrid behavior and toxicity as "we're all lost causes anyway". If someone needs a guide on how to starve or cut.. I'm going to assume they're young or very naive, and really shouldn't be on a site like this to begin with.
What I've observed is the two extremes that dominate many discussions: validate everything types on the basis of individuality, or the folks who get so sick of the hugbox culture they become disgruntled and speak up in assholish ways. And I can attest to being annoyed by the sheer stupidity or baity-ness of some threads, but that's when I started reducing my time here. Being a troll or devil's advocate to struggling people helps no one, even if the topic sounds ridiculous. I'm just very tired of the either defeatist comments on people trying to climb out of their hole, or the rather cruel types who insist that if you haven't already done it, your suffering must not be "as bad as theirs".
What you have in the end is people who leave altogether because the meta is not receptive to change, friction, or any sort of well meaning criticism; people get afraid to speak up because of being dogpiled, or they learn to pick their battles like I do, and just distance themselves entirely.
And regarding the whole idea of weaponization, with suicidality it is extremely common because of the stigma around passivity vs actively attempting, or having done it in the past. It's "easy" to argue, I suppose, you aren't seriously miserable enough if you haven't taken extreme action, but that's ignoring many circumstances and in large part what drives impulsive suicides. People are spiteful and need to prove it, because they are already in that dark headspace and feel they will not be heard or listened to otherwise. But there are also the bad actors who have weaponized it as a means to manipulate, as have many of my ex friends and lovers here done. And why I have so many of those from here is a story for another day, though I don't mind telling it either.
It's just one example, but people come here acting as if because it's a site for information on suicide, that somehow equals to always encouraging horrid behavior and toxicity as "we're all lost causes anyway". If someone needs a guide on how to starve or cut.. I'm going to assume they're young or very naive, and really shouldn't be on a site like this to begin with.
What I've observed is the two extremes that dominate many discussions: validate everything types on the basis of individuality, or the folks who get so sick of the hugbox culture they become disgruntled and speak up in assholish ways. And I can attest to being annoyed by the sheer stupidity or baity-ness of some threads, but that's when I started reducing my time here. Being a troll or devil's advocate to struggling people helps no one, even if the topic sounds ridiculous. I'm just very tired of the either defeatist comments on people trying to climb out of their hole, or the rather cruel types who insist that if you haven't already done it, your suffering must not be "as bad as theirs".
What you have in the end is people who leave altogether because the meta is not receptive to change, friction, or any sort of well meaning criticism; people get afraid to speak up because of being dogpiled, or they learn to pick their battles like I do, and just distance themselves entirely.
And regarding the whole idea of weaponization, with suicidality it is extremely common because of the stigma around passivity vs actively attempting, or having done it in the past. It's "easy" to argue, I suppose, you aren't seriously miserable enough if you haven't taken extreme action, but that's ignoring many circumstances and in large part what drives impulsive suicides. People are spiteful and need to prove it, because they are already in that dark headspace and feel they will not be heard or listened to otherwise. But there are also the bad actors who have weaponized it as a means to manipulate, as have many of my ex friends and lovers here done. And why I have so many of those from here is a story for another day, though I don't mind telling it either.
Last edited: