DeBreather purchase, too good to be true?

[JacobsCracker]

This device is supposed to seal to your face not allowing any outside air in. So not sure how the CO method would add to this? If there's a leak maybe ? Or it falls off, but the CO might not work either?

I was wondering if the Carbon Monoxide would leak through any gaps and help finish the job? Haven't really thought it through was just wondering about a failsafe in case of leaks.

Can I just ask, is mask leakage the only current concern?

 

[lmroch]

So.. How many reasons might this product fail by. Let us count the ways:

1. mask
2. extra tape around the mask.
3. connections
4. soda lime is old
5.
6.
7.
8.
9. user error
10. SI (edit)

 

[Living sucks]

I was wondering if the Carbon Monoxide would leak through any gaps and help finish the job? Haven't really thought it through was just wondering about a failsafe in case of leaks.

Can I just ask, is mask leakage the only current concern?

The major concern now is, do these work at all? A user already tried without success. And extra secured the mask with tape.

 

[JacobsCracker]

As Imroch says above. ^^

 

[GoodPersonEffed]

I wouldn't make it alarming. I would just say I've heard a report that one recipient attempted to use their device over the weekend, they duct taped any hose connections and duct taped the mask to their face and did not feel a thing and wore it for 30 minutes. They noted the granules turned purplish but has no other remarks.

@Living sucks and @Imroch, I'd like to share my thoughts about posting about this on the EI forum. If it's already been done, no big deal, these are just my thoughts.

As @Living sucks said, "no other remarks."

Folks here have asked for photos and additional information, and asked if s/he was going to report this to Richard, and @DownToGo never responded. That's his or her right, but without more information, we have nothing to go on but a few brief posts and then nothing.

As I recently mentioned on this thread, we're going to be hit from all sides about this product, and if the product not working for one person who won't respond to reasonable requests or even acknowledge them, then it's taking the unproven drama over to another forum. IF this is a pro-life tactic, taking it over to EI is doing the pro-lifers' work for them. If @DownToGo was freaking out to the point that s/he couldn't respond to reasonable requests, it's still taking an as-yet unsubstantiated freak-out over to EI.

Personally, I think it's best to be patient and wait for other members here to try the product and report back if there are problems, or try it and have their names crossed out.

 

[umniak]

If it works how could they self-ban? I don't know the db doesn't work and C may be selective or straight up scamming. Oh there's this cold going around and if you are "lucky" to die enough from it; you are drowning for days. Wish I wasn't such a p and drank my N when I had it.

 

[GoodPersonEffed]

If it works how could they self-ban?

If they do a goodbye thread, mods will ban them after a couple of days. If they self-ban, their names will be crossed out after 48 hours if they don't undo it. During those 48 hours, they can't post.

 

[Living sucks]

If they do a goodbye thread, mods will ban them after a couple of days. If they self-ban, their names will be crossed out after 48 hours if they don't undo it. During those 48 hours, they can't post.

Do you know how many good bye threads I've added to the SN attempt thread that are not banned? I don't thibk this is happening any longer.

 

[GoodPersonEffed]

Do you know how many good bye threads I've added to the SN attempt thread that are not banned? I don't thibk this is happening any longer.

That's true. They'd now have to tag the mod in the post as a reminder.

 

[nonamegirl]

How could this method fail, if a user had even duct taped the mask onto the face?? It shouldnt be possible at all.

I am seeing a huge red flag on this method :/ (DAMN I had hoped this would be our peaceful salvation)

 

[LMLN]

How could this method fail, if a user had even duct taped the mask onto the face?? It shouldnt be possible at all.

I am seeing a huge red flag on this method :/ (DAMN I had hoped this would be our peaceful salvation)

It seems that there had to be a leak in the system somewhere. Otherwise you could not have it on for 30 minutes without running out of oxygen.

 

[nonamegirl]

It seems that there had to be a leak in the system somewhere. Otherwise you could not have it on for 30 minutes without running out of oxygen.

Well, that's also concerning if one of the first reports had a leak in the systems. It just doesnt give me a good "vibe" about this whole thing.

 

[LMLN]

Well, that's also concerning if one of the first reports had a leak in the systems. It just doesnt give me a good "vibe" about this whole thing.

The instructions do describe how to check for leaks. I think it is wise to take a lot of time making sure the mask is leak free. And this is possible per the instructions. It's also important to check the other connections just to make sure nothing has come loose. The instructions on the rtd website are very detailed, if one carefully reads and follows them, I think this method could work very well. It cannot be done in a rush.
But you have to be comfortable. If not, it's best not to use this method I think.

 

[My_name_is_Luka]

I've been following the thread for a while. It all looks very over-designed to me.
The mask, the cylinders, the tubes, the plastic bag. Many connections, many elements, many possible leaks.
Wouldn't it be easier to buy a mask with a filter for small particles / dust, place the soda lime in a plastic bag (eventually in small filter bags) and wrap the plastic bag around the head? Same concept, only 1 bag with possible leaks.

 

[BaronVon]

Being a

How could this method fail, if a user had even duct taped the mask onto the face?? It shouldnt be possible at all.

I am seeing a huge red flag on this method :/ (DAMN I had hoped this would be our peaceful salvation)

This is a new device and i would keep with an open mind of its effectiveness, we have only had one documented attempt of usage on here, lets be honest this person could either be a genuine person who had a totally faulty device and method sold to him , did not have the set up of the device correct before usage or even a pro lifer trying to stop people looking at this as an option

I would be patient and i am sure more information will come through on this unit

 

[LMLN]

I've been following the thread for a while. It all looks very over-designed to me.
The mask, the cylinders, the tubes, the plastic bag. Many connections, many elements, many possible leaks.
Wouldn't it be easier to buy a mask with a filter for small particles / dust, place the soda lime in a plastic bag (eventually in small filter bags) and wrap the plastic bag around the head? Same concept, only 1 bag with possible leaks.

I think many years have been spent on this unit. It seems complicated, but I think this design is needed to increase reliability and comfort.

Being a

This is a new device and i would keep with an open mind of its effectiveness, we have only had one documented attempt of usage on here, lets be honest this person could either be a genuine person who had a totally faulty device and method sold to him , did not have the set up of the device correct before usage or even a pro lifer trying to stop people looking at this as an option

I would be patient and i am sure more information will come through on this unit

I agree. I hope EI gets more information out soon about it from other users.

 

[My_name_is_Luka]

this design is needed to increase reliability and comfort.

It is just a re-use of the re-breather used for other applications (and I believe that units used in anesthesia are more expensive); those re-breathers were designed with another target in mind: extremely comfortable design, portability or minimum coverage of the face of the user.
In a production line, ensuring quality at low price and setting up a fault-free production are a big problem, if the complexity of the device is larger.
And over-design is seen everywhere in engineering.
I don't argue that this design has a good comfort, but it has an user-dependent failure.
The extreme opposite would be sealing your head in a bag full of soda lime granules: uncomfortable, but extremely reliable, as long as CO2 buildup is kept low.
The right choice is in the middle. The idea of the soda lime is great.

Anyway: it should be reported to the producers. If they care about their business, they would try not to lose credibility.

 

[lmroch]

Spoiler

Spoiler

Spoiler

Spoiler

 

[Living sucks]

I wish we could get more info but I'm sure as we all know, failed attempts really mess you up worse. Especially when no one else knows you failed and you're all alone with your thoughts .

 

[lmroch]

"30 minutes. The granules in one canister began Turning Violet". - Could there have been an issue with the canisters or soda lime?

https://sanctioned-suicide.net/thre...too-good-to-be-true.30913/page-21#post-694168

 

[Donk]

"30 minutes. The granules in one canister began Turning Violet". - Could there have been an issue with the canisters or soda lime?

https://sanctioned-suicide.net/thre...too-good-to-be-true.30913/page-21#post-694168

How to Detect Soda Lime Exhaustion?

Dr. Truchetti explains how to recognize that soda lime is exhausted and why it matters.

www.dispomed.com

 

[qwerty32]

Besides dissecting the entire device down, has anyone heard of any successful use of the debreather?

 

[Notabadguy]

Besides dissecting the entire device down, has anyone heard of any successful use of the debreather?

The first bach was 100 Rebreathers and it was sold out in a few days. Nobody is returning to inform of success. Most people want to CTB priavately. It's what I think.

 

[Donk]

The first bach was 100 Rebreathers and it was sold out in a few days. Nobody is returning to inform of success. Most people want to CTB priavately. It's what I think.

im hoping there will be more updates in May PPH

 

[Living sucks]

It is just a re-use of the re-breather used for other applications (and I believe that units used in anesthesia are more expensive); those re-breathers were designed with another target in mind: extremely comfortable design, portability or minimum coverage of the face of the user.
In a production line, ensuring quality at low price and setting up a fault-free production are a big problem, if the complexity of the device is larger.
And over-design is seen everywhere in engineering.
I don't argue that this design has a good comfort, but it has an user-dependent failure.
The extreme opposite would be sealing your head in a bag full of soda lime granules: uncomfortable, but extremely reliable, as long as CO2 buildup is kept low.
The right choice is in the middle. The idea of the soda lime is great.

Anyway: it should be reported to the producers. If they care about their business, they would try not to lose credibility.

This is very personal to some ... i would rather be found with a device touted to be peaceful on my body than a plastic bag that looked like I did it impulsively, for my families sake.

 

[Brick In The Wall]

Don't think you won't be put on a list for purchasing this "product."

 

[GoodPersonEffed]

Don't think you won't be put on a list for purchasing this "product."

Don't think you won't be put on a list for using this site, using the Internet, or breathing oxygen, either!

 

[Brick In The Wall]

Don't think you won't be put on a list for using this site, using the Internet, or breathing oxygen, either!

That's so sweet. Someone actually cares about me!?

 

[GoodPersonEffed]

That's so sweet. Someone actually cares about me!?

I hope this doesn't push you over the edge, so step away from the SN and all sharp objects, but...

Spoiler

they care about them.

 

[Brick In The Wall]

I hope this doesn't push you over the edge, so step away from the SN and all sharp objects, but...

Spoiler

they care about them.

Oh you pushed me too far! Lookout microwave, cause here I come!