Very peaceful full hanging video

[Terrible_Life]

How did this person hang herself so peacefully? Unfortunately one can't see her set up, the knots etc so I wanted to ask some experts here how could she do it? My theory is that before she hang fully she already compressed the carotids to a point where she was nearly unconscious.

Young Chinese woman hangs herself in shower • GoreCenter

CHINA Young Chinese woman plagued by depression decided to end her own life. She hangs herself in the shower. During this, she is filmed on a camera that she had placed in a suitable place.

www.gorecenter.com

 

[CynicalCyanide]

This is indeed very peaceful. We can't know for sure. Maybe she hade painkillers or was high of some kind.

 

[Miss Anthropy]

I admire her courage and weep for her cats. I hope she is at peace now!

 

[33K1LLM3]

I'm really happy it was quick and mostly painless for her, but oh god, why does it have to be so easy for some people, and not others…

Also I hope those kitties went to another kind individual.

 

[Renato]

So peaceful and comforting. To me it looks like she really knows how to put minimal pressure to loose consciousness without putting immediately all her body weight on the neck. For a moment she puts a foot on the chair, but even in that moment the pressure on the neck is probably enough to keep cutting the blood flow.

After just 10 seconds of continued but light pressure she passes out and only after that she hangs fully by the neck.

 

[youpi]

All comments are saying it's fake. Thoughts ?

 

[Terrible_Life]

All comments are saying it's fake. Thoughts ?

don't take comments from gore sites serious. Most of them who have an account there are disgusting scum that enjoys people die. How should that woman faked it? I believe its real and my theory is she compressed the carotids perfectly while staying with one foot on the chair and thats exactly how i'll do my hanging. I tested it once it was actually a coincidence Because i stepped some steps down from the ladder and without realizing it the noose already compressed the carotids so strong that i was very close to get unconscious

 

[suyasuya]

That doesn't look like a suicide. You can tell by how relaxed her wrists and hands are. There isn't any of the usual decerebrate/decorticate posturing indicative of brain damage.

That being said don't quote me on that. I haven't completed my undergrad. It's just contradictory to the literature I've read about litigation hanging deaths and emergency medicine protocols.

Lemme pull up PubMed one moment.

 

[NoDeathNoFear]

The 'You may also like:' on that page is so... uhm...

 

[JesiBel]

It looks fake... the movement of her legs*, her arms remain placidly at her sides, almost inert...

*They look deliberately done, unlike the spasms generated by the body itself in response to the lack of oxygen in the brain.

 

[Terrible_Life]

How could she fake it and what would motivate someone to fake a hanging video? What would the person gain from that?

 

[Worndown]

Not everyone siezes. Some flop like a fish, some just hang there. Most are somewhere between.

 

[suyasuya]

How did this person hang herself so peacefully? Unfortunately one can't see her set up, the knots etc so I wanted to ask some experts here how could she do it? My theory is that before she hang fully she already compressed the carotids to a point where she was nearly unconscious.

Okay so first things first: By "peacefully" do you mean without convulsions? Or that you aren't struggling? When you see people convulsing in hanging videos that's not them struggling. Those are reflexes triggered by asphyxiation. You're unconscious at that point.

Update from my last response: I found a fun lil read! It's the chapter "Death by Hanging" in Essentials of Autopsy Practice (link). I've attached a PDF to this post.

The convulsion in successful hangings usually occur after the person losing consciousness. Here's the timeline for 14 hangings:


Nobody really knows why some people don't convulse when they die. There's a section that goes over an case study where someone hung themselves and their body remained motionless:

The only exception to this sequence was the unusual case of a hanging without decerebrate and decorticate rigidities [ 18 ]. A 52-year-old man hanged himself by completely suspending himself from a ring in the ceiling. When he stepped off the stool, the movement of the body stepping off the stool created a rotary movement around the ceiling's ring, and the body started to revolve around the ring. Apart from the rolling around the ceiling's ring, the body stayed motionless for the duration of the movie, and no decerebrate or decorticate rigidity was observed. It was suggested that the lack of usual motor responses in this particular case might have been caused by the vestibular stimulation of the rotary movement. It is well known that the decerebrate and decorticate postural reflexes are triggered by three types of afferent sensory information: muscle proprioceptors (sense changes of length or tension in muscles), vestibular receptors (detect head motion), and visual inputs (sense movement in the visual field). The vestibular system plays a particularly important role in the postural attitude of decerebrate and decorticate rigidities. In animal models, cutting the vestibular nerves or destroying the labyrinths abolishes the input from the vestibular system and reduces decerebrate rigidity. Stimulating the anterior lobe of the cerebellum also reduces decerebrate rigidity. In this exceptional case of hanging without decerebrate and decorticate rigidity, the revolving movement of the body is hypothesized to have interfered with the development of the postural attitude.

I checked the full case study and uhhh it's well over my head. Maybe someone with a better understanding of neurophysiology can chime in to explain that.

 

[JesiBel]

Nobody really knows why some people don't convulse when they die. There's a section that goes over an case study where someone hung themselves and their body remained motionless

The study says (pdf):

Spoiler

The man's body stayed motionless for the duration of the movie, and no decerebrate or decorticate rigidity was observed.

So.. he was completely inert.

Also the study says (pdf):

Spoiler

The second mechanism of death challenged by the studies of the Working Group on Human Asphyxia is the cardioinhibitory reflex by pressure on the baroreceptors in the carotid sinuses and the carotid body. If this cardioinhibitory reflex was an important mechanism of death in hanging, rapid almost instantaneous death should have been observed. The Working Group on Human Asphyxia has currently reviewed more than 30 cases of filmed lethal and nonlethal hangings. However, not a single rapid death was observed in all the lethal and nonlethal filmed strangulations. On the contrary, all lethal and nonlethal films analyzed so far have presented a strikingly similar pattern of agonal sequences.

The video:

The young woman isn't completely motionless, and her movements are very different from those usually seen in videos. Her arms are almost inert, and her legs occasionally move. In addition, she begins to "convulse" almost instantly. Only towards the end of the video, some abdominal movements appear to be seen.

The truth is that the video raises doubts in me.

We can't see her head or ligature, it's as if her entire upper part were fixed in one position.

@Terrible_Life_99 With some video manipulation and editing skills you can do wonders.. Why would someone fake a suicide? To manipulate, to seek attention, to hurt others... Humans do things to get something in return. Why would you film yourself? You want to be seen by someone, or leave a message.

It's unlike any other video I've seen, so I prefer to be cautious with this one.

 

[Gustav Hartmann]

If the video isn´t AI generated, I see no hint that it is fake. One can see no harness and if she would have used an orthopedic device to hang by the neck without any pressure on the neck (which are popular in China), why is her show so unspectacular?

The body responses to cerebral ischemia are multivarious. Wild convulsions of an unconscious person does not mean that her death is not peacful.

 

[hmnow]

I have seen quite a few hanging videos in my research and have found many seem to loose consciousness quickly, Their bodies may jerk but they appear unconscious, I read a study that reviewed death from hanging by watching their streamed videos, and the average unconsciousness was around 10 seconds - and only one went to 15 seconds

 

[tbh2023]

How did this person hang herself so peacefully? Unfortunately one can't see her set up, the knots etc so I wanted to ask some experts here how could she do it? My theory is that before she hang fully she already compressed the carotids to a point where she was nearly unconscious.

Young Chinese woman hangs herself in shower • GoreCenter

CHINA Young Chinese woman plagued by depression decided to end her own life. She hangs herself in the shower. During this, she is filmed on a camera that she had placed in a suitable place.

www.gorecenter.com

When you die you fight for your life while your soul is leaving you so there is no way to skip this pain and hanging is not peaceful. This movie could be fake as well as the other sn videos.

 

[Worndown]

When you die you fight for your life while your soul is leaving you so there is no way to skip this pain and hanging is not peaceful. This movie could be fake as well as the other sn videos.

Technically this statement would make all death qualify as painful.
I take it you have a more peaceful option planned. It might be best to talk up that method rather than talk down methods you will not use.

Watch her neck. At the start, her shoulders are almost at the top of the frame. During the video she settles down about an inch which is consistant with hanging.

 

[Cauliflour]

Why were her legs twitching like that? Also how was the filming stopped if nobody else seems to be on view? Was this a very short livestream?

 

[JesiBel]

Why were her legs twitching like that? Also how was the filming stopped if nobody else seems to be on view? Was this a very short livestream?

In these two threads, you can read information about the hanging process and the body's response to the stop of oxygenated blood flow to the brain:

Spoiler

Thread 'Videos of succesful hangings'

Videos of succesful hangings

Anyone who want to post videos you have found of good hangings in full suspension? (For educational purposes) Here are the ones I've found. I think they all go unconscious in just a matter of seconds. - https://watchpeopledie.tv/h/suicide/post/49322/man-recorded-hanging-himself-in-facebook...

sanctioned-suicide.net

Thread 'Input on hanging experience'

https://sanctioned-suicide.net/threads/input-on-hanging-experience.208993/post-3037970

@suyasuya also attached a pdf here..

I also wonder how these kinds of videos get onto websites... If not through streaming... will the police leak them? Who knows..

 

[Cauliflour]

In these two threads, you can read information about the hanging process and the body's response to the stop of oxygenated blood flow to the brain:

Spoiler

Thread 'Videos of succesful hangings'

Videos of succesful hangings

Anyone who want to post videos you have found of good hangings in full suspension? (For educational purposes) Here are the ones I've found. I think they all go unconscious in just a matter of seconds. - https://watchpeopledie.tv/h/suicide/post/49322/man-recorded-hanging-himself-in-facebook...

sanctioned-suicide.net

Thread 'Input on hanging experience'

https://sanctioned-suicide.net/threads/input-on-hanging-experience.208993/post-3037970

@suyasuya also attached a pdf here..

I also wonder how these kinds of videos get onto websites... If not through streaming... will the police leak them? Who knows..

Thank you!

(i'm not a psycho i'm just too curious for my own good)