how one user described it, "young beautiful women". Are you too of the opinion that personality is in fact not relevant and looks are all-encompassing?
I remember that post, assuming it's the same one. To quote the post (although not exactly/directly in case the user doesn't want me to name them):
'38 Male. This is why I'm going to CTB, there's no reason to be alive for me if I can't have sex and affection from young beautiful women. The frustration I feel every time I see one is ineffable. Only death can free me from this curse.'
I related to this statement a lot, although I'm an asexual (or something to that degree) with no interest in sex. I guess this puts me in a relatively unique position to explain, at least, how it is for me. A cel, as opposed to an incel lol.
(TL;DR below. EDIT: Apologies, even the TL;DR is long...)
This quote sums up probably the reason that I most desire to CTB too. Not the sex, I have no interest in that. If the most attractive girl in the world, with the best personality, threw herself at me begging to have sex with her, I really wouldn't want to, or even know how to tbh. I've always said I'd give it a go if I had a girlfriend that really wanted me to, as I think it's only fair to compromise in a relationship. She'd have needs, I presume, and I would be a bad boyfriend if I didn't at least try to meet those needs. But I'm saying this just to stress that I don't want sex, have no interest in it and never have done.
Consequently, I can't really say how it is for unasexual guys but, for me, even I still get this feeling of... I'm not even sure how to describe it, but it's the worst feeling I ever mentally experience. I call it 'horniness' but naturally I'm not quite sure if that's an accurate comparison to what unasexual people experience as horniness. For me it's just like a great depressing feeling. I'm told horniness feels good, so I'm not sure if it really counts as actual horniness because this feeling really feels awful to me.
But the feeling is most frequently triggered by seeing women that I find attractive. I suppose I can understand why from the perspective of (I have to presume) people that don't experience this same feeling, this may seem superficial. But the only way I can describe it is... a very primal or natural feeling. It's an emotion, I suppose. I've even blocked people on websites before for frequently posting pictures of girls I find attractive. Not in a malicious way, but merely because I don't want to see those pictures because it hurts to be reminded that girls I find attractive exist and I can't be with them. It can legitimately ruin my day, my mood completely sinks. This probably sounds bad or pathetic, but I'm just saying as accurately as I can how it feels. And I think people that experience this feeling probably agree that it's bad and pathetic, which is yet another reason to want to CTB because of it, I suppose.
This being said, I'm not sure if this is an incel thing. Or, rather, a thing that's
caused by being an incel. I think most of the people that post pictures of attractive girls are incels. Yet, they do it because they enjoy it. I ask them 'don't you feel agony at seeing the most beautiful girls on the internet and knowing that you can never be with them?' and they just tell me that 'these girls have brought me immense joy and pleasure!'. So maybe it's just a different mindset or mentality thing, as opposed to an incel thing.
TL;DR:
But I think it's a miscalculated jump to make the correlation between having this feeling and believing that looks matter over personality. This isn't to say many guys don't favor looks over personality, I'm sure they do, but I believe this is separate from the particular agonizing feeling that I believe the person you mentioned was expressing. The agonizing feeling that propels so many people, or me at least, to want to die to be relieved from it. This being said, please keep in mind it maybe different for guys that
are after sex, I'm just saying my own perspective.
I think that, ultimately, a big part of where the feeling comes from is a feeling of uselessness and having missed out. Relationships, etc, are a part of life. A big part. Some consider them to matter more than anything else. The user I quoted was 38 and had never been able to experience this. That doesn't feel good, to know, for whatever reason, you've been incapable of experiencing this, normally natural and inherent, part of life. Knowing he missed out on the ability to experience those normal things that people generally do is awful, and seeing 'young beautiful women' is a reminder of this and brings with it the agonizing 'horniness'.
I relate to this, it's an agonizing feeling to know you missed out on those experiences/connections and are unable to have them. Despite what people say, there's obviously a time limit on these things, on having those connections that most people do growing up. If you don't get to experience that, you missed out and you're going to feel terrible and like there's just no point anymore.
You said you have no problem finding partners in the past, so imagine if you'd been unable to. Imagine never having experienced that and never being able to, even if you wanted. And being unable to know
why you can't have them, as I suspect is the case for most people in this situation. And there's probably many potential reasons for why that is, dependent on the individual. For some, they might just have a terrible personality. For some, they might just not be good-looking enough themselves. Some might have confidence issues. Some might be autistic, or something like that, and just have immense trouble with social relationships in general. Some of these things can be improved, and others can't. They're all walls, whether collapsible or indestructible, around a person's ability to live a normal life. It's consequently no wonder, at least to me, why so many people feel trapped with death as their only relief.
To be involuntarily celibate, or just to not have had any connections you desire, while most other people around you are having them is agony.
And I say this as someone who
can get partners. My problems are quite separate and way too complicated, I won't go into it here because this comment is already ridiculously long LOL.
But I believe I relate to the feeling that the person you quoted expressed, so I just wanted to give my perspective on it. It's primarily a feeling of having missed out. It's not about favoring looks over personality in a partner. It's simply the looks that evoke the pain.