my ex was a very difficult person to talk to. He would bottle up all his feelings and opinions to himself. If I asked if something was wrong or bothering him, he would say "nothing" or that everything was "ok". I can't be in a relationship where someone doesn't know how to communicate at all. Trying to get him to talk to me was a hard job. I think he wasn't mature enough and he has to work on himself. Our relationship statted to fail as I got tired of him not opening up. He started chatting with someone only over text, I saw it and I decided to end the relationship. I understand he could have trouble expressing but it is one own responsibility to communicate. If they don't want to communicate and expect us to guess them out, I prefer to just leave.
Sounds very much like my experience. Amazing guy, kind, smart, you name it. I tried so hard to get him to open up, and he did, but rarely, and it felt like only under duress. He started counselling, and so did I. His inability to communicate with me led to a couple of blowouts and I realised I was putting in all the work to smooth things over, every time. But because he never said much - and my probable BPD - I never felt like things were truly resolved. I sucked it up and tried to move on. But last week I realised all the journalling letters to him wasn't getting me any closer to having the emotional connection we were lacking, and, after almost two years, I ended things. I am distraught - he may not have understood me but he was patient and kind and thoughtful.
I have a way to go with working on myself and I think he does too. Unfortunately we couldn't do this whilst together.