Lol Cake123, I think we all know who's he talking about. But yeah didn't like his points, he really paints this forum and people who post here as some kind of sick cult that pushes people to die and has a sinister agenda and philosophy. What a load of shit. They just can't comprehend that some people have issues that cannot be resolved and unfortunately see only solution in dying. The vast majority of people I meet here are really nice and are just regular people who were unfortunate to end up here.
What's even worse is that they advocate for people here to go through even worse hell in our lives, throwing out suggestions of violence or prison against forum users, because they do not sincerely believe that someone can be suicidal longer than a week or two, and not be helped by the resources that are currently out there. If they truly cared about the wellbeing of suicidal people, they wouldn't advocate for such punitive measures.
You can tell the people in the comments are projecting their own experiences/beliefs about suicidiality onto others. For example, thinking that because they are easily influenced by social media and make impulsive decisions, that everyone else must share those characteristics as well.
They genuinely refuse to believe that longterm suicidality exists, and thus are are allowed to promote dangerous rhetoric that a person who doesn't go through with the act must be faking having issues of their own, and that they are psychopathic and potential sexual predators. It's batshit insane, but for whatever reason people are lapping it up at face value and doing no critical thinking.
Of course, there will always be dangerous people on any website and you must be cautious about who you speak to/appearances are deceiving, but sickos and scammers typically get outed and most people here will speak up and publically share when someone has behaved inappropriately towards them. The vast majority of people here, like you say, just suffered a bad lot in life and have nowhere else to talk about their problems because they've been driven out of everywhere else by being too negative or too open about what's happened in their lives.
The people in those comments are the exact reason why lots of us can't speak anywhere but the forum, those types turn downright nasty when you tell them nothing has helped you. How many of us have experienced abuse from others when we continue to be sick/disabled/ill? The sympathy runs out real fast when you disagree with these types of people on mental health related matters, they immediately start attacking your character and conviction when you don't magically get over whatever is bothering you.
It just blows my mind how people can accept such loaded accusations at face value, especially when they are coming from a music youtuber of all people who has no expertise about the brain, sociology, or human behavior. What sort of message are they sending here when they tell their audience that you either have a temporary crisis and immediately get better, or otherwise you're a liar and a fake and you aren't actually suffering?
I genuinely don't know how people can believe this junk and be so short sighted. It's like their compassion for suicidal people runs out after about 5 minutes, then it's acceptable for them to bully anyone whose lived experience goes against their narratives.