Thanks so much for doing this—and reporting back to us. A while ago there was another member here who was adamant that Pegasos would not contact the U.S. Embassy. He even got defensive about it. But with all due respect to him, the fact is that both Dignitas and Pegasos are bound by the laws of Switzerland, no exceptions. So Pegasos is either disorganized, or perhaps just lying to potential clients. I hope for Pegasos sake, and their clients, that it is the former.
I have no idea who the member was and didn't read the conversation, but this is an anonymous forum and we can't know others' motivations or if they're telling the truth. Another possibility to add to those you mentioned is that the defensiveness was an evasion technique. Sometimes people brandish strong emotions to get others to back down from their positions.
I remember how vocally and publicly adamant
@fightingsioux was against goodbye threads and tributes, yet when he at last (allegedly) had assisted euthanasia, another member posted a tribute and got vehemently defensive about it when others called that out in respect for and deference to
@fightingsioux's explicitly stated wishes. You may be referring to the same member, but it's not really relevant except as it relates to your own personal consideration of what you mentioned, unless you want to support what you said above by quoting the comments you alluded to. Personally, I don't think it's necessary for my own edification, but someone else might if they want to follow up and not just take your word for it. Not trying to provoke you! Just standing back and looking at your comment from multiple perspectives. Hope you can understand that and not feel any disrespect or challenge that are not present with me.
To wrap up about not knowing who's at the keyboard or why, even
@fightingsioux could be a persona who acted from a script. But his consistent behaviors demonstrated a consistent character, so I always leave room for doubt because it's an anonymous and open forum, but overall I would be willing to give much weight to anything he said, based on his consistency, and because anything he claimed about methods or assisted euthanasia is verifiable.