Lime Sulfur acid thoughts

[hankly]

Heyo back with another silly question.

i have 1l of lime sulfur, whats "better", vinegar (5-6% acid) or HCL containing thing (10%).

i have all the protocol and safety in place for others, just want to look at cost/benefit of the acids, prefer no chemical burns but unsure if vinegar would really work.

safe travels

 

[nobodycaresaboutme]

I think HCL is the better choice. Just because HCL is a strong acid and vinegar (acetic acid) is a weak acid.
HCL containing toilet bowl cleaner Sunpole (9.5% HCL) is frequently used for the hydrogen sulfide method in Japan.

[Suicidal poisoning due to hydrogen sulfide produced by mixing a liquid bath essence containing sulfur and a toilet bowl cleaner containing hydrochloric acid] - PubMed

A 21-year-old man was found dead in a car. There were 9 empty bottles of 610HAP (a 440 g bottle of a liquid bath essence containing 160-195 g/kg sulfur) and 10 of Sunpole (a 500 mL bottle of a toilet bowl cleaner containing 9.5% HCl) in the car. The car doors were sealed with tape, and there was...

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

Sunpole Image

 

[hellocana]

Heyo back with another silly question.

i have 1l of lime sulfur, whats "better", vinegar (5-6% acid) or HCL containing thing (10%).

i have all the protocol and safety in place for others, just want to look at cost/benefit of the acids, prefer no chemical burns but unsure if vinegar would really work.

safe travels

Did you attempt this method?