T

TiredHorse

Enlightened
Nov 1, 2018
1,819
I have the sneaking suspicion that the entertainment industry deliberately depicts completely ineffectual methods of suicide in order to avoid promoting effective self-euthanasia.

So just to de-bunk the ones I see referenced here again and again, by the hopeful/desperate, this is the list I've come up with off the top of my head for possibilities to avoid:

Cutting your wrists --especially across the long axis of your arm, but even lengthwise is highly unlikely of success. It does hurt, though. (Full confession: I tried this when I was 15, so this trope is near and dear to me.)

Shooting yourself in the temple --almost guaranteed to not kill you, but it will likely turn you into a vegetable.

Shooting yourself under the chin --it may well blow off a big piece of your face, but it probably won't kill you.

Dropping an electrical appliance into your bath --either the internal electrics of the device or the household fuse will blow before it even has time to pop out your dental fillings. It'll almost certainly hurt, though.

OD'ing on any one OTC drug --Big Pharma made this an impossibility long ago, but that doesn't mean it won't destroy your internal organs and leave you alive and in agony.

OD'ing on a random combination of OTC drugs --again, Big Pharma has made this unlikely.

Gassing yourself with the car's exhaust --hasn't been an option since catalytic converters became standard 40 years ago, and each new advance in fuel economy translates to more complete fuel combustion that makes it even less likely to succeed.

Suffocating yourself with a bag over your head, while fully conscious --CO2 build up will trigger your hypercapnic alarm and your body's instincts will override your will to die.

Any others?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Escaper Boy, lemmeeleev, sif and 31 others
J

JazzyWolfWhistle

Specialist
Sep 10, 2018
347
Most or all of them. Where do we get our ideas about suicide? From TV. We are so screwed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, sif, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals and 7 others
Smilla

Smilla

Visionary
Apr 30, 2018
2,549
I attempted at 20 with the plastic bag, a bottle of wine and otc sleeping aids.

Can confirm hypercanic alarm was experienced, and was horrifying and painful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, sif, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals and 12 others
M

MsM3talGamer

Voluntary deletion
Nov 28, 2018
1,504
In the scene of "13 Reasons Why" she makes cutting her wrists look really easy. I hate to see impressionable young people trying to copy this ineffectual way of CTB. They're more likely to end up with horrific injuries to their arms and surviving.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, sif, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals and 13 others
Xerxes

Xerxes

Invisible
Nov 8, 2018
936
Devils Advocate where Keanu's wife slits her throat with a piece of glass. She slices across cutting through her windpipe and esophagus and then bleeding out immediately. Not the case since the jugulars are located a bit higher near your thyroid glands. Cutting through the windpipe will make your head look like a Pez dispenser and it's painful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals, Lifeisatrap and 6 others
Pegasus

Pegasus

Experienced
Dec 15, 2018
258
Jumping from a low ledge and they die in movies but irl you can live with bad injuries.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals, galaxyencrypted and 6 others
Johnnythefox

Johnnythefox

Que sera sera
Nov 11, 2018
3,129
I don't know if the Gas oven one is still relevant, used to be seen in older movies.
Then again I have an electric oven.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, Pegasus, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals and 6 others
J

JustLosingMyself

Mage
Sep 4, 2018
544
I don't know if the Gas oven one is still relevant, used to be seen in older movies.
Then again I have an electric oven.
No,
There is no CO mixed in city gas in Europe any longer. Hasn't for a good while
 
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals, Lifeisatrap and 4 others
Smilla

Smilla

Visionary
Apr 30, 2018
2,549
I don't know if the Gas oven one is still relevant, used to be seen in older movies.
Then again I have an electric oven.


Sylvia Plath died this way.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals, TheCrow and 6 others
Johnnythefox

Johnnythefox

Que sera sera
Nov 11, 2018
3,129
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals, TheCrow and 4 others
Severen

Severen

Enlightened
Jun 30, 2018
1,819
Movies...TV shows...mostly BS...designed to entertain or brainwash or both. Real life is much more horrific.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals, Pegasus and 10 others
Johnnythefox

Johnnythefox

Que sera sera
Nov 11, 2018
3,129
Movies...TV shows...mostly BS...designed to entertain or brainwash or both. Real life is much more horrific.
Yes, when I was growing up I thought everyone in the US had a big house with a white picket fence.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals, mattwitt and 8 others
Severen

Severen

Enlightened
Jun 30, 2018
1,819
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals, TheCrow and 4 others
O

OkTotti

Wizard
Nov 6, 2018
616
Those days are long gone.
Those days never existed... i live in the US and i never had a white picket fence nor did i knew anyone that had one
 
  • Like
Reactions: PrincessInWhite, lemmeeleev, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals and 7 others
Severen

Severen

Enlightened
Jun 30, 2018
1,819
Those days never existed... i live in the US and i never had a white picket fence nor did i knew anyone that had one

Seriously?
 
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals, Lifeisatrap and 1 other person
M

MsM3talGamer

Voluntary deletion
Nov 28, 2018
1,504
I don't know if the Gas oven one is still relevant, used to be seen in older movies.
Then again I have an electric oven.
Not sure cooking your head is a nice way to go. :P
 
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals, galaxyencrypted and 4 others
Johnnythefox

Johnnythefox

Que sera sera
Nov 11, 2018
3,129
Those days never existed... i live in the US and i never had a white picket fence nor did i knew anyone that had one
I thought everyone led the "happy days" life!
 
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals, therhydler and 2 others
Kdawg2018

Kdawg2018

Still here...
Nov 10, 2018
272
I grew up in California, I never realized that southern accents were real until I moved out of state. I just thought they were something on TV
 
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals, Pegasus and 5 others
Retched

Retched

I see the chaos in your eyes.
Oct 8, 2018
837
Another fantastic piece of writing by tiredhorse...this one needs to go in resources.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals, gingerplum and 4 others
Xerxes

Xerxes

Invisible
Nov 8, 2018
936
Those days never existed... i live in the US and i never had a white picket fence nor did i knew anyone that had one

Come to the Deep South, notably Alabama or Georgia. You'll have a nice white picket fence, giant plantation house, and historic grave markers where slaves were buried.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals, Pegasus and 2 others
Xerxes

Xerxes

Invisible
Nov 8, 2018
936
On topic: Also if you stick a lead pencil in your nose, pointy end first, and then slam your head on the desk. You won't die, but will have a piercing headache.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, Tragoedia Vitae, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals and 6 others
T

TiredHorse

Enlightened
Nov 1, 2018
1,819
On topic: Also if you stick a lead pencil in your nose, pointy end first, and then slam your head on the desk. You won't die, but will have a piercing headache.
Ah Jeeze! Was that seriously portrayed as a way to kill yourself? Really!?

A "piercing" headache, indeed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals, gingerplum and 2 others
Xerxes

Xerxes

Invisible
Nov 8, 2018
936
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, Tragoedia Vitae, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals and 3 others
O

OkTotti

Wizard
Nov 6, 2018
616
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals, TheCrow and 1 other person
Stillnotsure

Stillnotsure

Experienced
Dec 18, 2018
245
I have the sneaking suspicion that the entertainment industry deliberately depicts completely ineffectual methods of suicide in order to avoid promoting effective self-euthanasia.

So just to de-bunk the ones I see referenced here again and again, by the hopeful/desperate, this is the list I've come up with off the top of my head for possibilities to avoid:

Cutting your wrists --especially across the long axis of your arm, but even lengthwise is highly unlikely of success. It does hurt, though. (Full confession: I tried this when I was 15, so this trope is near and dear to me.)

Shooting yourself in the temple --almost guaranteed to not kill you, but it will likely turn you into a vegetable.

Shooting yourself under the chin --it may well blow off a big piece of your face, but it probably won't kill you.

Dropping an electrical appliance into your bath --either the internal electrics of the device or the household fuse will blow before it even has time to pop out your dental fillings. It'll almost certainly hurt, though.

OD'ing on any one OTC drug --Big Pharma made this an impossibility long ago, but that doesn't mean it won't destroy your internal organs and leave you alive and in agony.

OD'ing on a random combination of OTC drugs --again, Big Pharma has made this unlikely.

Gassing yourself with the car's exhaust --hasn't been an option since catalytic converters became standard 40 years ago, and each new advance in fuel economy translates to more complete fuel combustion that makes it even less likely to succeed.

Suffocating yourself with a bag over your head, while fully conscious --CO2 build up will trigger your hypercapnic alarm and your body's instincts will override your will to die.

Any others?


To play devils advocate... I've been a medic for a long long time. Shooting yourself in the temple or under the chin can and does succeed often but it isn't 100%. It's mostly a game of ballistics and physics. If you use a .22 there isn't enough projectile mass or velocity to cause the necessary damage. That said I had a guy kill himself with a .22 temple shot, just dumb luck. Why people fail often has to do with the angle of the firearm to the brain and flinching, literally, as they pull the trigger. Had one guy use a shotgun and buckshot and ended up crawling around his garage for three hours without a face. If you choose to use a gun,especially black powder muzzle loader if you live in a gun restricted country, do your research first! It is a reliable method if you know what you are doing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lemmeeleev, sif, Tragoedia Vitae and 5 others
T

TiredHorse

Enlightened
Nov 1, 2018
1,819
To play devils advocate... I've been a medic for a long long time. Shooting yourself in the temple or under the chin can and does succeed often but it isn't 100%. It's mostly a game of ballistics and physics. If you use a .22 there isn't enough projectile mass or velocity to cause the necessary damage. That said I had a guy kill himself with a .22 temple shot, just dumb luck. Why people fail often has to do with the angle of the firearm to the brain and flinching, literally, as they pull the trigger. Had one guy use a shotgun and buckshot and ended up crawling around his garage for three hours without a face. If you choose to use a gun,especially black powder muzzle loader if you live in a gun restricted country, do your research first! It is a reliable method if you know what you are doing.
Absolutely correct. As an EMT, I've seen case reports of any number of dumb-luck suicides even when I haven't seen the actual cases, and as a long time shooter, I know even a .22 can get the job done with the right aim and a steady hand.

However, as you are undoubtedly aware, the intention of the post is to debunk the common tropes that might otherwise be seen as infallible methods. Just because there's a slim chance you could succeed at a Hollywood method doesn't mean you should embrace it as a sure-fire technique to end your life.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sif, Tragoedia Vitae, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals and 2 others
Stillnotsure

Stillnotsure

Experienced
Dec 18, 2018
245
Absolutely correct. As an EMT, I've seen case reports of any number of dumb-luck suicides even when I haven't seen the actual cases, and as a long time shooter, I know even a .22 can get the job done with the right aim and a steady hand.

However, as you are undoubtedly aware, the intention of the post is to debunk the common tropes that might otherwise be seen as infallible methods. Just because there's a slim chance you could succeed at a Hollywood method doesn't mean you should embrace it as a sure-fire technique to end your life.
True. But let's remember, no method is 100%. I think the people on this site can confirm survival of every method possible. I learned that when it's your time to go, death will find a way. No matter what.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sif, Tragoedia Vitae, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals and 3 others
T

TiredHorse

Enlightened
Nov 1, 2018
1,819
True. But let's remember, no method is 100%. I think the people on this site can confirm survival of every method possible. I learned that when it's your time to go, death will find a way. No matter what.
Agreed: no method is 100% certain. But if you want death to find its way reliably, efficiently, and expediently --ideally even peacefully-- it might be better to stay away from methods that have high cinematic value but low efficacy.

The intention of this thread is both to steer people away from the most egregiously ineffective methods and to reinforce the idea that they should research their chosen method carefully.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tragoedia Vitae, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals, Pegasus and 4 others
TAW122

TAW122

Emissary of the right to die.
Aug 30, 2018
6,804
Not sure if this was mentioned before, but jumping into a volcano. Hollywood or at least fiction makes it seem like you slowly get consumed by lava/magma, but that's not the case. Getting close to a volcano (if one even lives near an active one) would result in really uncomfortable heat (and you might die of asphyxiation or burning to death before you reach the actual magma or lava. Also when you step into lava, I think (since over half the human body's composition is water) you vaporize and explode when you hit lava/magma.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sif, Tragoedia Vitae, RaphtaliaTwoAnimals and 3 others

Similar threads

Rational Actor
Replies
2
Views
153
Suicide Discussion
an alien
an alien
LonelyKitten
Replies
33
Views
6K
Suicide Discussion
iloverachel
I
Octavia
Replies
28
Views
4K
Suicide Discussion
jarik
jarik
EmbraceOfTheVoid
Replies
18
Views
3K
Suicide Discussion
filthyrottendirty
F