C

checkouttime

Visionary
Jul 15, 2020
2,904
I would imagine a person cannot exhale against a rate of gas coming in from a tube at 15L per minute, and therefore couldn't push CO2 down the tube.

Where the nuts connect to threads, i would advise using plumbers gas tape. to make sure of a good seal and no leakage.(i think some people have used plumbers ptfe tape, but gas is better). you could also wrap gas/ptfe tape around the fitting that has the 1 pipe going into 2 and then tighten the jubilee clips, which could also make for a better seal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: theunderdog
theunderdog

theunderdog

Member
Jun 17, 2021
38
We decided in the end to go with a second set up. Much less to worry about then. If one of us had a fit or something or knocks the bag of the other accidentally ect. Not sure when our bus is due but I feel relaxed knowing we're ready.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Greenberg
LADY007

LADY007

Specialist
Feb 25, 2020
372
Hey, I am planing to use the exit bag as well. Don't know when exactly it will happen but I want everything to be ready and thought through when I feel ready to go.

I: I am not sure if it is possible to commit it in a lying position? As far as I know one should sit upright if using the exit bag. I forgot the exact reason but it has something to do with the physics of the gas and the exit bag . (I will use nitrogen and not Argon - not sure if that is making any difference for this)
one should assure that the body doesn't fall aside after fainting which could be solved by using somthing like a armchair.

II: Do you think it is 100% okay to have the gas bottle lying while using it? I have though about using a pod filled with sand to stabilize the bottle in an upright position (I mentioned it with a sketch in one of my previous threads)
Derk Humphries from Final Exit showed a picture of himself in an armchair with loose bands around each arm of the chair to use after you have the gas and bag all set. You start everything and slip your arms out under the bands(ropes, etc) so they keep your hands from upsetting the bag from movement as you are going unconscious.
 
R

Riomhaire1

Member
Jul 14, 2021
23
P1*V1 = P2*V2 ....
9 liquid liters at 2000 psi = 1224 liters at 14.7 psi ( ie atmospheric pressure)

1224 litres at 35 liters per min total flow = 34 min --- approx 17.5 liters down each of the two hoses.
--- though toward the very end --- when pressure really drops as bottle is almost empty- the flow will drop too when not adjusted ...

-if it is argon through an argon gauge - should still be approx correct / calibrated even on a cheap regulator / flowmeter

----- so you are correct and that other poster does not understand this simple gas law.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Leaks :

Have you leak checked it ?

Hose seems too big / heavy / incompressible --- ie difficult to make a gas tight seal using a pipe clamp - so - the hose connections all look a little dodgy to me - especially the one to the gas cylinder.

The regulator/ flowmeter output flowing gas will be at an approx fixed pressure from the flow gauge - likely 50psi - for a 1/4 inch / 6mm inner diameter hose- this is higher pressure than a rock hard bike tyre.
Not sure the hose won't just blow off - but looks almost certain to leak at least partially ... Turn it on and see ... have you done this ?
Maybe it is ok ?

That kind of thread reinforced pvc hose is not very compressible - it is pretty rigid- and the "barb" coming off the regulator/flowmeter looks like a 1/4 in FLARE connector - not a proper barb connector -- so even with the hose clamp - I can't see this being very gas tight -- but maybe it is ok.

Pipe clamps can only exert very limited force -- especially the cheapo ones with open notched not just grooves in metal - try scandvik clamps

Turn it on - and wipe some soapy water with a sponge around the joint - bubbles ? yes / no ?
Without a tight joint here - and such long and big bore hoses your setup will not work -- gas will not flow out the end of such long and huge hoses.

Likewise for your splitter -- leaks - have you checked ?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The other poster who mentioned tape is mistaken - it will not help you.
PTFE tape is for water joints - plumbers joints -- not gas lines
( I know they have special gas tape but it is a crutch and only for metal to metal)
--- and often makes gas joints even worse and anyway is for metal to metal joints ONLY.
Metal to metal joints are meant to have the metal deform and make a gas tight seal - plastering teflon tape everywhere does not usually help for gases.

You do not have metal to metal joints - you have a metal clamp trying to compress a hose against a metal barb --- adding more soft material in the sandwich does not help
You already have the compressible material there ( the hose ...) - covering the sharp barb threads with tape is counterproductive - bad idea ...

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hose too big / heavy -- cannot tape to bag

Seems impossible also to pre-fill the bag before pulling it down over head - given thick heavy hose not attached to bag on the inside with tape ( would not hold it)
--- this means that quick loss of consciousness is not going to happen per PPH book

-- even trying to squish the bag while on your head - to remove all the air/oxygen when starting - with the hose in there -- and then pulling down over head -- seems like it cannot work -- hose will keep bottom of bag open at neck - so will have loads of air in there that you have to first exhaust or breathe/use up --- prolonging the entire thing

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

--- what is to stop hose just falling down out of bag / slipping out under its own weight once consciousness is lost ?
Presumably you would be sitting up -- it is a heavy tube - gravity ... you might move around too ...
Are you going to tape it to your forehead/face / hair ? there is nowhere else above neck height ...
What keeps it in place ?
I cannot see that it will stay put - for absolute certain - this is not a game.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Seems to be a big problem when can't get an adapter from large 1/4in ( or metric equivalent) flare type connection ( male or female ) from Co2 reg/flowmeter -- down to lightweight thin O2 tubing.
Some people do manage to get slightly thinner soft clear pvc tubing and just stretch / butcher it on to the 1/4 in ID regulator output --for a photo
- but unless it is as thick walled as yours - to take 50psi - it will not take more than 20 psi - per mfg spec - not enough -- so end up with a thick heavy pvc hose just like the one you have coming off the gas cylinder 1/4in ID / 3/8 in OD or bigger.


https://sanctioned-suicide.net/attachments/20200922_174753-jpg.45276/

https://sanctioned-suicide.net/attachments/img_20181023_183046831-1-jpg.2332/
https://sanctioned-suicide.net/attachments/img_20181021_090635-jpg.2253/
https://sanctioned-suicide.net/threads/inert-gas-cylinder-regulator-general-refresher-summary.30657/

Stuck ...
--------------------------------------------------

Standard Argon/N2 regulators / flowmeters all have this problem - big heavy hoses -- and the supplier welding hoses with metal connectors on each end are even worse
Can't easily buy the medical type regulators with the lightweight thin 6mm O2 type tubing that can tape to the bag -- unless go to MDB.
Not otherwise sold to the public any more.

Can't buy a simple Medical twist N2 flowmeter/regulator meant to go with O2 type mini tubing
- unless pay Max Dog Brewing in Australia - $300+ - and wait 8 weeks - if customs do not stop it ( for definite in the EU they will - likely too in USA ) -- then what ?
( for a $40 part ... that is what the O2 one costs - freely available- but money is useless when dead so just pay up) - though they likely sell so few have to charge this to cover cost of having a human deal with it - and nothing else - single product

eg -- https://www.walmart.com/ip/EverOne-...ction-Brass-Sleeve/707584465?wmlspartner=wlpa

-- this $27 one for oxygen -- cannot buy the one for nitrogen if not a medical professional -- and the cylinder connection end is different by design for O2/N2

Note --- the MDB / other N2 parts will over read for Argon -- N2 meter set for 15l /min N2 will only flow 12 l/min Argon -- not enough - but can set it to 25l/min N2 which will give 30 l/min Argon

At least MDB are reputable - around for decades - with a genuine interest in helping people - with identifiable people there -- but the price is just so much - and the wait too long - and customs/delivery an issue too. At least it will work - just cannot be sure can get it through the mail.
Other reputable / real suppliers will not sell to non medical customers - eg WT Farley in USA

Other website sources -- not interested in profit taking resellers of cheapo $10 Alibaba untested / uncalibrated crap that could explode when connected to 2000 psi cylinder and take your eye out. And prices/shipping issues not much cheaper than MDB but without the reliability track record.
Or wake up brain damaged but not dead because flowmeter failed part way through or gave the wrong ( too low or too high) flowrate



-------------------------------------------------

Any solutions on connnecting thin O2 tuning to std gas cylinder connections ? --- aside from unhelpful vague "find a barbed connector adapter" -- which is just restating the problem and not giving a solution.

OR --- how to hold thick / heavy hose inside thin fragile 19x 24 in ( approx 14 litre) oven bag -- to pre-inflate bag -- and then to keep it there afterwards ?
 
Last edited:
  • Love
Reactions: kurororo and Greenberg
R

Riomhaire1

Member
Jul 14, 2021
23
Derk Humphries from Final Exit showed a picture of himself in an armchair with loose bands around each arm of the chair to use after you have the gas and bag all set. You start everything and slip your arms out under the bands(ropes, etc) so they keep your hands from upsetting the bag from movement as you are going unconscious.
Exhaled Co2 is heavier than air- and will tend to go out elastic/open neck -- though all the turbulence form hose gas flow will likely mix it all up and swirl it around - then carry it out the elasticated neck of the bag as intended

Helium and nitrogen are lighter than air -- so need to sit up -- and stay sitting up even after losing consciousness - gas fills bag from the top down.

Argon is heavier than air -- will tend to fall to the lowest point in the bag - fills bag from the bottom up -- might be able to get away with lying down for this - though ideally don;t want anything touching the bag to snag it etc if you roll over -- sitting up best

Don;t know about the armchair ... when collapse after lose consciousness - if fall on floor then bag/ tubing all at risk
--- maybe sitting on a bed against corner walls / pillows so cannot fall
 
  • Like
  • Hugs
Reactions: Rolo and Greenberg
Greenberg

Greenberg

nitrogenexit.blogspot.com
Jun 28, 2020
1,063
No it is not, completely painless and peaceful. Best!
 
  • Like
Reactions: GasMonkey and reasonablylost
R

RowdyH999

Student
Mar 17, 2021
136
Thanks for your details response. That's what I love about this community. People engage and try and offer solutions. The gas tank is 9L liquid so about 2.3M3 so I calculated it as having approx 1500 gas litres. At 30L per min that's about 50mins of gas each. But I'm now definitely considering a second canister just because I worry about the gas all going into one bag. I guess as soon as we have the bags above our head we will see how they inflate. Could be a good test.
Maybe they have a check valve you can get and put in line to prevent backfeed. However controlling the amount to each line is still up in the air
 
  • Love
Reactions: Greenberg
R

Riomhaire1

Member
Jul 14, 2021
23
This an adapter to 4mm OD PU tubing.

It is not clear what size the ID of your tuning is -- if it is 1/4 in / 6mm then can use std O2 medical breathing tuning - can get on Amazon -- would be much easier than your heavy hoses. Maybe there is some other barb adapter you can get.

IF not - then could get this 3/8 in to 4mm OD adapter cable -- then buy some 4mm OD PU tubing.
Need to get a cutting tool - couple of pounds cost - like a stapler but holds a razor blade to give a clean 90 deg angle cut on the tubing -- otherwise the press fit push in connector will leak.
The 4mm PU tubing is somewhat rigid but would be easier to deal with than your hoses.
P1*V1 = P2*V2 ....
9 liquid liters at 2000 psi = 1224 liters at 14.7 psi ( ie atmospheric pressure)

1224 litres at 35 liters per min total flow = 34 min --- approx 17.5 liters down each of the two hoses.
--- though toward the very end --- when pressure really drops as bottle is almost empty- the flow will drop too when not adjusted ...

-if it is argon through an argon gauge - should still be approx correct / calibrated even on a cheap regulator / flowmeter

----- so you are correct and that other poster does not understand this simple gas law.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Leaks :

Have you leak checked it ?

Hose seems too big / heavy / incompressible --- ie difficult to make a gas tight seal using a pipe clamp - so - the hose connections all look a little dodgy to me - especially the one to the gas cylinder.

The regulator/ flowmeter output flowing gas will be at an approx fixed pressure from the flow gauge - likely 50psi - for a 1/4 inch / 6mm inner diameter hose- this is higher pressure than a rock hard bike tyre.
Not sure the hose won't just blow off - but looks almost certain to leak at least partially ... Turn it on and see ... have you done this ?
Maybe it is ok ?

That kind of thread reinforced pvc hose is not very compressible - it is pretty rigid- and the "barb" coming off the regulator/flowmeter looks like a 1/4 in FLARE connector - not a proper barb connector -- so even with the hose clamp - I can't see this being very gas tight -- but maybe it is ok.

Pipe clamps can only exert very limited force -- especially the cheapo ones with open notched not just grooves in metal - try scandvik clamps

Turn it on - and wipe some soapy water with a sponge around the joint - bubbles ? yes / no ?
Without a tight joint here - and such long and big bore hoses your setup will not work -- gas will not flow out the end of such long and huge hoses.

Likewise for your splitter -- leaks - have you checked ?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The other poster who mentioned tape is mistaken - it will not help you.
PTFE tape is for water joints - plumbers joints -- not gas lines
( I know they have special gas tape but it is a crutch and only for metal to metal)
--- and often makes gas joints even worse and anyway is for metal to metal joints ONLY.
Metal to metal joints are meant to have the metal deform and make a gas tight seal - plastering teflon tape everywhere does not usually help for gases.

You do not have metal to metal joints - you have a metal clamp trying to compress a hose against a metal barb --- adding more soft material in the sandwich does not help
You already have the compressible material there ( the hose ...) - covering the sharp barb threads with tape is counterproductive - bad idea ...

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hose too big / heavy -- cannot tape to bag

Seems impossible also to pre-fill the bag before pulling it down over head - given thick heavy hose not attached to bag on the inside with tape ( would not hold it)
--- this means that quick loss of consciousness is not going to happen per PPH book

-- even trying to squish the bag while on your head - to remove all the air/oxygen when starting - with the hose in there -- and then pulling down over head -- seems like it cannot work -- hose will keep bottom of bag open at neck - so will have loads of air in there that you have to first exhaust or breathe/use up --- prolonging the entire thing

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

--- what is to stop hose just falling down out of bag / slipping out under its own weight once consciousness is lost ?
Presumably you would be sitting up -- it is a heavy tube - gravity ... you might move around too ...
Are you going to tape it to your forehead/face / hair ? there is nowhere else above neck height ...
What keeps it in place ?
I cannot see that it will stay put - for absolute certain - this is not a game.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Seems to be a big problem when can't get an adapter from large 1/4in ( or metric equivalent) flare type connection ( male or female ) from Co2 reg/flowmeter -- down to lightweight thin O2 tubing.
Some people do manage to get slightly thinner soft clear pvc tubing and just stretch / butcher it on to the 1/4 in ID regulator output --for a photo
- but unless it is as thick walled as yours - to take 50psi - it will not take more than 20 psi - per mfg spec - not enough -- so end up with a thick heavy pvc hose just like the one you have coming off the gas cylinder 1/4in ID / 3/8 in OD or bigger.


https://sanctioned-suicide.net/attachments/20200922_174753-jpg.45276/

https://sanctioned-suicide.net/attachments/img_20181023_183046831-1-jpg.2332/
https://sanctioned-suicide.net/attachments/img_20181021_090635-jpg.2253/
https://sanctioned-suicide.net/threads/inert-gas-cylinder-regulator-general-refresher-summary.30657/

Stuck ...
--------------------------------------------------

Standard Argon/N2 regulators / flowmeters all have this problem - big heavy hoses -- and the supplier welding hoses with metal connectors on each end are even worse
Can't easily buy the medical type regulators with the lightweight thin 6mm O2 type tubing that can tape to the bag -- unless go to MDB.
Not otherwise sold to the public any more.

Can't buy a simple Medical twist N2 flowmeter/regulator meant to go with O2 type mini tubing
- unless pay Max Dog Brewing in Australia - $300+ - and wait 8 weeks - if customs do not stop it ( for definite in the EU they will - likely too in USA ) -- then what ?
( for a $40 part ... that is what the O2 one costs - freely available- but money is useless when dead so just pay up) - though they likely sell so few have to charge this to cover cost of having a human deal with it - and nothing else - single product

eg -- https://www.walmart.com/ip/EverOne-...ction-Brass-Sleeve/707584465?wmlspartner=wlpa

-- this $27 one for oxygen -- cannot buy the one for nitrogen if not a medical professional -- and the cylinder connection end is different by design for O2/N2

Note --- the MDB / other N2 parts will over read for Argon -- N2 meter set for 15l /min N2 will only flow 12 l/min Argon -- not enough - but can set it to 25l/min N2 which will give 30 l/min Argon

At least MDB are reputable - around for decades - with a genuine interest in helping people - with identifiable people there -- but the price is just so much - and the wait too long - and customs/delivery an issue too. At least it will work - just cannot be sure can get it through the mail.
Other reputable / real suppliers will not sell to non medical customers - eg WT Farley in USA

Other website sources -- not interested in profit taking resellers of cheapo $10 Alibaba untested / uncalibrated crap that could explode when connected to 2000 psi cylinder and take your eye out. And prices/shipping issues not much cheaper than MDB but without the reliability track record.
Or wake up brain damaged but not dead because flowmeter failed part way through or gave the wrong ( too low or too high) flowrate



-------------------------------------------------

Any solutions on connnecting thin O2 tuning to std gas cylinder connections ? --- aside from unhelpful vague "find a barbed connector adapter" -- which is just restating the problem and not giving a solution.

OR --- how to hold thick / heavy hose inside thin fragile 19x 24 in ( approx 14 litre) oven bag -- to pre-inflate bag -- and then to keep it there afterwards ?
Solved -- found barbed adapters on amazon -- go from 1/4 in flare to 1/4in barb --- fits std O2 tubing
1626763309176 Argon Nut & Nipple x 1/4" Hose Barb, Mig Tig Welding Fitting Inert Gas, 2 Sets

Will work with a US regulator OUTPUT ✔ Female 9/16" x 18 nut and male 5/"8 UNF-18RH fitting- 1/4" Hose Barb Adapter Included.

1626763501069
3 Pack Oxygen Supply Tubing - Standard Connector - Premium Clear Crush Resistant Oxygen Tubes - 16.4 feet - with Free Connector
 
Last edited:

Similar threads

MeowWantsToGoHome
Replies
5
Views
405
Suicide Discussion
imadeahugemistake
imadeahugemistake
B
Replies
9
Views
515
Suicide Discussion
athiestjoe
athiestjoe
Z
Replies
4
Views
2K
Suicide Discussion
finalincarnate
F
W
Replies
3
Views
434
Suicide Discussion
kudaphillips
K