Reincarnation Case - What are your thoughts about this Case?

[Terrible_Life_99]

https://med.virginia.edu/perceptual-studies/wp-content/uploads/sites/360/2017/04/REI42-Tucker-James-LeiningerPIIS1550830716000331.pdf

 

[pthnrdnojvsc]

I'll never believe in any kind of reincarnation afterlife etc. a human is just another animal true or not? is evolution true or not ? it's true humans evolved from a single cells ancestor. all life descended from a single ancestor. a human is just an animal, cells a machine , chemical reactions that's it. do machines or chemical reactions reincarnate ?

imo it's very easy for a human to make up a story. and even when small children are involved how do we know the parents didn't create this hoax like for example repeatedly telling the kid this story and even maybe hypnotizing the children .

i'll never believe anything a human says ever . only reproducible evidence or experiments.

how many eleborate hoaxes, scams, lies have there been?

there is a huge incongruety between what people say they experienced or saw and any real evidence.

there have been hundreds or more of people saying they saw a religious aparition. same thing for NDEs . even more for ufo sightings. however there is no hard evidence to match these many stories. for example there is no video of any of these things or no instrument has never dected anything of these kinds of things nor even a trace of them or an energy field nothing .

there is not one single contact sound from any alien also . and we know they have giant radio telescopes listening for that . but how many ufo sightings and stories? i'm not saying there isn't any intelligent life in the universe . there could be other intelligent life in some faraway star. but why the silence why no scientific sighting of an alien.? i'm saying that the reports of ufo's here are Earth are false imo. i don't think any aliens have visited the Earth.

edit after posting the above i found this link

Crash and Burn: James Leininger Story Debunked - Cup of Nirvana

“Debunk (verb): to show that something is less important, less good, or less true than it has been made to appear.” – Cambridge English Dictionary Beginning at age two in the spring of 2000, James Leininger began exhibiting behaviors and … Continue reading →

michaelsudduth.com

 

[Cosmophobic]

 

[Terrible_Life_99]

I'll never believe in any kind of reincarnation afterlife etc. a human is just another animal true or not? is evolution true or not ? it's true humans evolved from a single cells ancestor. all life descended from a single ancestor. a human is just an animal, cells a machine , chemical reactions that's it. do machines or chemical reactions reincarnate ?

imo it's very easy for a human to make up a story. and even when small children are involved how do we know the parents didn't create this hoax like for example repeatedly telling the kid this story and even maybe hypnotizing the children .

i'll never believe anything a human says ever . only reproducible evidence or experiments.

there have been hundreds or more of people saying they saw a religious aparition. same thing for NDEs . even more for ufo sigthings. however there is no hard evidence to match these many stories. for example there is no video of any of these things or no instrument has never dected anything of these kinds of things nor even a trace of them or an energy field nothing .

The child knew explicit details about that pilot. Details that weren't even mentioned in any ww2 books or documentary but he knew them, how is that possible?

 

[pthnrdnojvsc]

The child knew explicit details about that pilot. Details that weren't even mentioned in any ww2 books or documentary but he knew them, how is that possible?

and how do we know the parents or another adult didn't tell these stories to the child ? that's just one way i see it could be a hoax . many other ways that i haven't thought of and i just thought of it for a little bit.

if i find out some rarely known info . and then repeatedly tell it to a small child and tell him the story ...

do you believe in evolution? do you believe that a human brain cell is almost identical to a brain cell in a fly? it is because both descended from the same ancestor

why is there no evidence of any reincarnation, ghosts, soul ,afterlife , magic anything even after hundreds of years of people trying to find evidence. there are billions of video cameras in the world on smart phones and not one video .

of course as ai videos improve we'll probably see more hoaxes. but they don't even dare say it's real now even with ai.

edit after posting the above i found this link

Crash and Burn: James Leininger Story Debunked - Cup of Nirvana

“Debunk (verb): to show that something is less important, less good, or less true than it has been made to appear.” – Cambridge English Dictionary Beginning at age two in the spring of 2000, James Leininger began exhibiting behaviors and … Continue reading →

michaelsudduth.com

 

[divinemistress36]

Most people are atheists on here so you probably wont get to many people with beliefs on reincarnation

 

[doneforlife]

Here's the thing. The laws of God ( by extension, the laws of universe) are universal and apply equally to all irrespective of gender , race , culture , country etc. Example: Gravity. Gravity suddenly doesn't change for one person because there is something unique to that person.

So if there is reincarnation (at all) and it is designed not to be remembered... NOBODY will remember.

And if you don't/can't remember a phenomenon , it's as good as non existent. Just do good, be a good human being..that's all there is to it.

 

[Cosmophobic]

Here's the thing. The laws of God ( by extension, the laws of universe) are universal and apply equally to all irrespective of gender , race , culture , country etc. Example: Gravity. Gravity suddenly doesn't change for one person because there is something unique to that person.

So if there is reincarnation (at all) and it is designed not to be remembered... NOBODY will remember.

And if you don't/can't remember a phenomenon , it's as good as non existent. Just do good, be a good human being..that's all there is to it.

Exactly.

Not to mention one person becoming another is essentially meaningless. There can't be a transference when what is being transferred is lost in the process. Unless you just fall back on the concept of a soul.

 

[heydude56]

I dont know if this is truly real or not.. but i do think it's possible that some sort of reincarnation is definitely possible (At least personally)

 

[doneforlife]

Exactly.

Not to mention one person becoming another is essentially meaningless. There can't be a transference when what is being transferred is lost in the process. Unless you just fall back on the concept of a soul.

I had read the concept of reincarnation prevalent in Buddhism. It doesn't speak about soul reincarnation as it doesn't believe in a soul . The concept was a bit difficult to understand. But it's way different than how the world projects reincarnation to be. I didn't understand much though.

 

[Cosmophobic]

I had read the concept of reincarnation prevalent in Buddhism. It doesn't speak about soul reincarnation as it doesn't believe in a soul . The concept was a bit difficult to understand. But it's way different than how the world projects reincarnation to be. I didn't understand much though.

Yeah Buddhist rebirth and karma is hard to understand and there's tons of interpretations. Schopenhaeur tried to simplify it by suggesting the will (a kind of world soul) continually incarnates in different forms but there's no transmigration of the soul.

 

[starboy2k]

reincarnation is just another coping mechanism for the fear of dying/death.

we've been over this shit time after time again

 

[mellow]

I have brain damage and it's hard to read long text. But I really, really hope reincarnation is not true. Tupac said "my only fear of death is reincarnation", that is how I feel too. I mean an afterlife is scary, too.

I had a Buddhist "friend" that really freaked me out about not ending my life, when I got injured 5 years ago. Here is some of the stuff she wrote to me then:

It seems like you are asking two questions: one, is suicide ever justified and two, is your case such a case. In answer to the first, I would say I'm not sure if it ever is the right thing to do but if it is, it would be very very very very very very rare. And is your case such a case, I would say no. I think in order for you to choose suicide, you must understand what will happen when you die, and that you do not know. And what will the consequences be of suicide? From a Buddhist perspective, you will likely create a situation in which your future reincarnations will become addicted to suicide and you will do it over and over causing so much pain to yourself and others. This is the risk you take if you decide to kill yourself: a cycle of suffering much larger than you can fathom. You may be in the midst of such a cycle currently which means that breaking that cycle would be very difficult and that is what you stand to gain in future lives if you don't kill yourself. This is what I understand about suicide.

You will die one day no matter what, and they say that your state of mind at the time of death greatly impacts your trajectory of the bardo and rebirth. Killing yourself is a very very very difficult way to enter those next phases. Now they say at the time of death no matter what, you experience the clear light, you merge with god so to speak, the problem is that it won't stick, you won't stay merged if you cannot recognize it. So after that beautiful experience of nirvana and heaven, you continue on through the afterlife to much more scary and difficult experiences and eventually take rebirth based on what is familiar to you, to your mental habits and karma. If you die by suicide then you may take a rebirth from a parent who is suicidal for example which would again be a difficult life.

From the outside I can say with 100% certainty that you do have options, although I know you don't feel that way. Every day that you don't kill yourself is actually incredibly brave and meritorious. And as time goes on, your state of mind will change because all things all ways change. How your mind changes depends on you.

I am speaking very honestly here. This what my teachers have taught me.

I just think no one knows for certain, even the Buddhists don't know. And she said "all things all ways change", but brain damage is permanent... I cannot change the physical damage.

Another thing, I noticed the subject of this case study was born in April 1998. There was an astrologer on tiktok that said people born from January to May of 1998 have "past lives fighting in religious wars including the Crusades." But I dislike astrology now when I used to find it fun pre-injury, now it disturbs me... wouldn't it mean that everything is predestined, and we don't have freewill? So what are we doing here, what is the point of any of this if it's already set up, to unfold a certain way?

Lastly, I don't understand how reincarnation works when you consider overpopulation. I heard there are more people alive today than have ever lived/existed. So maybe some of us are reincarnated/had past lives, while others are new souls living our first life...?

 

[LostZombie]

Irrational belief system I call it. It came from faith, to believe without evidence. As a human who attempts to be rational in most situations, I the only proof of it is because old text says so. It's honestly disturbing how much we can believe without major proof. Along with the stupid arguments of "how do you know, you can't disprove it" I always then tell those people that gravity is just a theory...

Just saying, I can't disprove your beliefs, so why don't you disprove a theory, it should be easy.