Is this full of BS?

[rs929]

I was googling assisted suicide and euthanasia and I arrived to this site

11. Not a rapid or peaceful death

www.australiancarealliance.org.au

This seems to be some pro lifer scaremonging BS but at the same time, maybe it's true to some degree? Maybe peacefulness can't be achieved in 100% of the cases, even with N?

 

[justanotherfailure]

I would think that would be true to a certain degree, since the human body naturally really doesn't want to die and does just about everything it can to prevent people from killing themselves. That's also not a very good reason for euthanasia being illegal, since most people who decide to kill themselves feel like their lives cause more pain than the amount they will feel when dying, so whether these statistics are true or not, it's not really a meaningful argument

 

[chernobylmosqut]

I was googling assisted suicide and euthanasia and I arrived to this site

11. Not a rapid or peaceful death

www.australiancarealliance.org.au

This seems to be some pro lifer scaremonging BS but at the same time, maybe it's true to some degree? Maybe peacefulness can't be achieved in 100% of the cases, even with N?

This is the goofiest thing I've ever read in my entire life. They have data but they're re-contextualizing it to fit their narrative. It looks like they take a bunch of rare cases and cases where the people administering euthanasia used experimental cocktails to back their argument. For instance, regarding the US prisoners and lethal injection, I can tell you right now they don't check much for quality control. The cheap cocktails they use for the death penalty is not the same type of care one would use for something like swiss assist.

 

[Forveleth]

This is cherry-picking data to fit their narrative. Bunch of garbage.

 

[Pale_Rider]

I think Netherlands use a death capsule. I could be wrong, but I'll call BS. But will note lethal injections in the US often have issues.