Drowning vs SN

[karmaisabitch]

How drowning is a painful way to go but SN is encouraged here? It makes no sense in drowning you will die in minutes vs drinking nasty SN that turns your blood to ink is easier?? According to SASU..

 

[Jorms_McGander]

You're not considering the survival instinct. You can drink something far easier than you can drown yourself

 

[karmaisabitch]

How

You're not considering the survival instinct. You can drink something far easier than you can drown yourself

it's easier? When you know it's poison and have a lot of failing risk! Look at how many goodbyes we have here using SN but they comeback the next day in the ER? This is here I'm not going far..

 

[ferrie]

Drowning is one of the most painful ways to die (other than brutally violent methods). Other than SWB or drugging yourself, there is no way to mitigate the pain that is experienced when your lungs fill with water. On the other hand, symptoms of SN if the protocol is followed seem to be more discomfort than pain. The effect of SN on your blood shouldn't cause pain because you should be unconscious by that point, and even if you're not, you won't actually feel methemoglobinemia happening. There may be some panic from tachycardia and respiratory depression, but nothing nearly as extreme as the SI experienced in drowning

 

[DreamEnd]

How

it's easier? When you know it's poison and have a lot of failing risk! Look at how many goodbyes we have here using SN but they comeback the next day in the ER? This is here I'm not going far..

Most of those who comeback have called for help. If you don't call anyone to disrupt your attempt chances are it will go the way you want it to go

 

[karmaisabitch]

Most of those who comeback have called for help. If you don't call anyone to disrupt your attempt chances are it will go the way you want it to go

It's because it's very painful! I don't know what to do anymore or how to die

Drowning is one of the most painful ways to die (other than brutally violent methods). Other than SWB or drugging yourself, there is no way to mitigate the pain that is experienced when your lungs fill with water. On the other hand, symptoms of SN if the protocol is followed seem to be more discomfort than pain. The effect of SN on your blood shouldn't cause pain because you should be unconscious by that point, and even if you're not, you won't actually feel methemoglobinemia happening. There may be some panic from tachycardia and respiratory depression, but nothing nearly as extreme as the SI experienced in drowning

But you can't be sure because you didn't try!

 

[SuicidalBoredom]

Most of those who comeback have called for help. If you don't call anyone to disrupt your attempt chances are it will go the way you want it to go

Can someone share the threads where people came back from a SN attempt so we can read it?

 

[DreamEnd]

It's because it's very painful! I don't know what to do anymore or how to die

But you can't be sure because you didn't try!

It's not "very" painful. SI just comes into play. The discomfort is present but it's not "very painful"

 

[SadTitan]

seems like you want to argue more than listen.

 

[karmaisabitch]

It's not "very" painful. SI just comes into play. The discomfort is present but it's not "very painful"

Thank you appreciate your response!

seems like you want to argue more than listen.

definitely not arguing with you!!

 

[rozeske]

This is not the first "why is SN loved" post. It's ok for everyone to have a method of choice. It all just depends on accessibility, personal preference and the information you have about the method. You seem to have a lot misinformation about SN but it's ok to not want it. Just whatever method you endup with, do a very thorough research and let it be something that suits you <3

 

[iloverachel]

Drowning seems more painful and harder to do due to SI
It's so tragic that euthanasia isn't available for those who want an easy and painful death
I hope you eventually find the peace you deserve my friend

 

[karmaisabitch]

This is not the first "why is SN loved" post. It's ok for everyone to have a method of choice. It all just depends on accessibility, personal preference and the information you have about the method. You seem to have a lot misinformation about SN but it's ok to not want it. Just whatever method you endup with, do a very thorough research and let it be something that suits you <3

And we can't even get it so.. thank you so much

Drowning seems more painful and harder to do due to SI
It's so tragic that euthanasia isn't available for those who want an easy and painful death
I hope you eventually find the peace you deserve my friend

Thank you so much, my friend!

 

[ferrie]

It's because it's very painful! I don't know what to do anymore or how to die

But you can't be sure because you didn't try!

I mean I have drowned before???

 

[bobcat01]

Drowning just sounds way worse to me.

 

[Yarani]

Can someone share the threads where people came back from a SN attempt so we can read it?

SN Successful and Unsuccessful cases 2023 update

I have combined and added all the brief summary of all the attempts, assumed successful and unsuccessful, of SN suicide. These are all posts that the member has made to document the method, news articles, and scientific articles. If I have missed any I apologise and it would be great if you can...

sanctioned-suicide.net

SN Success rate 83%. Less than 20% reported pain?

https://www.mdpi.com/1660-4601/19/21/13996 44/53 of those that took it on purpose died (89% of men died, 67% of women, but the sample size for women was smaller) Even 57% of those that were hospitalized died In 95 cases, it was possible to collect information relating to the symptoms (Figure...

sanctioned-suicide.net

 

[LostSoul1965]

How drowning is a painful way to go but SN is encouraged here? It makes no sense in drowning you will die in minutes vs drinking nasty SN that turns your blood to ink is easier?? According to SASU..

Honestly why do you keep going around in circles on this? Your dislike for SN method is obvious but why keep posting on the same subject? The information is the same. Nobody is forcing it on you. Seems counter productive and time consuming. Many here like it as a proven method and obtainable by most but by the same token others don't. If it's not for you that's okay.To each their own and i hope you find peace in whatever you decide. Every method has it's own set of challenges. SI is a beast in any situation.

 

[Fantasy22]

If you don't like SN, don't do it. There's many methods out there I hope you can find one that you prefer like drowning

 

[makingaplan]

How

it's easier? When you know it's poison and have a lot of failing risk! Look at how many goodbyes we have here using SN but they comeback the next day in the ER? This is here I'm not going far..

How many is that?
Did they do it correctly?

 

[karmaisabitch]

How many is that?
Did they do it correctly?

I'm not expert on using SN so I'm not sure how many or if they did it correctly.

 

[karmaisabitch]

If you don't like SN, don't do it. There's many methods out there I hope you can find one that you prefer like drowning

Thank you so much