• Hey Guest,

    We wanted to share a quick update with the community.

    Our public expense ledger is now live, allowing anyone to see how donations are used to support the ongoing operation of the site.

    👉 View the ledger here

    Over the past year, increased regulatory pressure in multiple regions like UK OFCOM and Australia's eSafety has led to higher operational costs, including infrastructure, security, and the need to work with more specialized service providers to keep the site online and stable.

    If you value the community and would like to help support its continued operation, donations are greatly appreciated. If you wish to donate via Bank Transfer or other options, please open a ticket.

    Donate via cryptocurrency:

    Bitcoin (BTC):
    Ethereum (ETH):
    Monero (XMR):
N

noname223

Archangel
Aug 18, 2020
7,284
Thus far only on episode was aired. I am like a really huge Ghost in the Shell fan. I am not sure either Death Note or Ghost in the Shell is my favorite anime franchise.

I am never hyped about a new anime TV series usually. I am usually always too late when it comes to trends. I am the last one who watches such shows usually. I really like Fullmetal Alchemist (Brotherhood): I introduced the series and many others to my friends when I was younger. A friend told me to read Daemons of the Shadow Realm. I bought me one volume but never read it. Then there was a stream of the series even on German (I prefer German dub a lot). Now I watch it and the series is damn good. It is really a refreshing approach to anime. It is something new, creative and original. The setting is pretty pretty amazing and innovative. Thus far it doesn't come close to Fullmetal Alchemist. But I only watched a few episodes.

I am hyped since months about the the new The Ghost in the Shell(2026) series. Last year when I went through a lot. I started to re-watch Gits SAC. And I love this series so much. I watched the films and Arise afterwards. There is one film with a really bad German dub with a cheap cast. And it makes one movies so much worse in my ranking. I read all the articles and I read speculations from fans. And many were concerned it is aired on Amazon Prime. Usually this means a really poor dub. I assumed for a long time I had to watch it with subs or on English. I underestimated how popular the franchise was. There is a German dub even with the original cast. It sounds really good. But maybe I am a noob. I am not a huge anime fan anymore. I watched the episode very closely. It is very dense, colorful and high paced. I had to rewind some scenes. I will probably watch the episode again. I looked at the manga. Read parts of it. And I was aware the anime is quite different to the manga. The new 2026 series is closer the manga. A lot closer to the the series imagined by Masamune Shirow. It is also interesting the different interpretations of Gits by different producers.

I like the philosophical questions with Gits. I have to say in many instances I am quite impressed by the new series. They did a good job. For me it is very important that it is very close to the manga because this is what the anime franchise of Gits is missing. I find it interesting when Motoko isn't all the serious anymore. I alslo like her personality to be more cheeky. For me this makes the protagonists even deeper because they have so many facets.

I have now a really weird criticism. But this is something that bothers me. The approach to nudity in the 2026 series. Gits is always about the interplay of biology and new technologies. And in most interpretations of the series there is a lot of nudity. Not always as fanservice even though there is a lot of fanservice in the manga. But I have the feeling the Gits 2026 censors a lot of aspects of the managa on this issue. And one reason is probably the marketing and the question whether it fits to the mainstream target group. Anime was for teenagers/kids. I don't want hardcore pornography as in the manga. The next episode will be about the junk jungle. And I think the scene most fans are aware of will be either extremely censored or just cut out. I really dislike the approach there is some fanservice e.g. Motoko is embarrassed about some things. But I had to re-watch the scene a couple of times because I didn't get why she was actually embarrassed. There are some allusions but they are pretty hard to understand. One could see into her consciousness and I think in the manga there were sex scenes or something like that and in the 2026 there was showns like some bodies and you really have to be into the universe to understand what they wanted to hint to. I find this incredibly annoying and ridiculous. It gives me the feeling that the target group is way younger than actually conceptualized. Maybe I am a little bit too critical. Usually I am not a huge fan of fanservice. But if you adapt the original manga it feels distorted to cut all these scenes out.

On most other aspects I am very satisfied thus far. There is more light humor. People who only the SAC approach or the films might be confused about that. But actually it is part of the series and for me it contributes to the complexity of it.

What do you think?
 
Last edited:
  • Informative
Reactions: katagiri83
N

noname223

Archangel
Aug 18, 2020
7,284
In my opinion the second episode was slightly less impressing than the first one.

The pacing is too high. I had to rewind often. The story is very complex and I want to understand it fully. I have the advantage I know the universe though.The animations are amazing. They put a lot of effort in it.

The most interesting thing about this adaption is that it is very close to the manga original. I really enjoy to compare the adaption of the original manga of different approaches to this universe. There are really interesting differences. Mainly comparing the 2026 series with the first film and Stand Alone Complex.

After writing the first review I thought maybe I was a little bit too harsh concerning censorship. However, the second episode proved me right. The infamous junk jungle scene was heavily censored. I knew they cannot show a fisting scene. But I mean this was very different to the manga. I think Amazon was more brave with off campus. And I mean Gits has a rating of TV-MA (Mature audience only) why is there is need to censor it that much. It is part of the originak manga a lot. Just because the target group is a mass audience having to censor it. Why? This will be the only adaption very close to the orignal managa. So I am disappointed and I dislike censorship in general. Animes are not only for children.
 
  • Like
Reactions: katagiri83
N

noname223

Archangel
Aug 18, 2020
7,284
Oh I didn't comment on the third episode. Makes sense a lot of shit happened on that day.

Today I watched the fourth episode. And I have the feeling the series gets better and better. I am not sure though whether I find episdoe 3 or 4 currently the best.

I will comment on number 4. It reminded me a lot of the movie Innocence. The basis is obviously the manga though. I think the story from the manga that was used for part of Stand Alone Complex but mostly for the second movie Innocence.

The manga version that was adapted in episode 4 makes more sense and is slightly less complicated. I think the slap stick humor wasn't that fitting. There was a very emotional plot about the abduction of children. And the villains were portrayed as some really weird idiots.

The episode/managa tries to be several different things at the same time. And I am not sure whether that works out that well. Thus far the humor wasn't annoying for me (criticized by many fans). But in this episode it sort of backfired. I think it is an ambitious project. And it is very hard to adapt the manga. I will skimm through thee manga to come to more conclusions.

I am very glad the German dub is good. With Amazon that's always a gamble.
 

Similar threads

N
Replies
1
Views
349
Offtopic
Forever Sleep
F
N
Replies
10
Views
719
Offtopic
BradGuy123
B
lohre2000s
Replies
22
Views
845
Offtopic
VanillaCake
VanillaCake
N
Replies
2
Views
529
Offtopic
Seneca65AD
S