this post popped up in my feed again, hi cherub!
i tried talking to one of my friends about my suicidal thoughts and he got upset with me since i couldn't really talk about anything besides looking up methods. i realized that i couldn't get a firearm until i turn 21 after i had spent a week researching guns and how to properly position them, so that ended up being a waste of time.
i'm still thinking about ctbing (i have a note on my phone of locations i can do it at lol) but i won't tell my friend anymore because i know he doesn't like hearing it. most people will get distressed, tell you to talk about something else, or say that they'll call the cops on you if you say you're getting really depressed. this forum seems to be the only place you can actually be open with your feelings, and having separate forums for suicide and wanting to recover is cool for people that feel both ways. i don't have a therapist, but that's the only for real for real way to talk about how you're feeling without distressing someone close to you. before going on this forum i'd have bad intrusive thoughts and i'd google what to do, and i'd just get stuff about not killing yourself or to talk to your friends. constantly looking up self help advice because i wanted to feel better always made me feel worse. it can be really frustrating to get worse but not be allowed to mention it to anyone ♡
Hi, sorry you went through that
I don't think it is best to think in absolutes regarding talking to people about this. True in some cases it can suck or even turn ugly. Like you say a lot of people don't know how to react and do so poorly. Others have good intentions and care for you and might go into lifeguard mode, just trying desperatedly to understand and keep you from doing that. Talking to someone who cares for you just about how to kill yourself has high chances of them just freaking out yeah. If you allow for some nuance and tact there is a source of comfort there.
It's a case by case basis, you shouldn't reject it altogether because it can help a lot and others have shared experiences of that here.
You just have to use your own judgement and knowledge of that person.
There are those who, if you engage with it propperly, can empathize and share comfort.
It's a hard subject and there is no way around that.
Also get how shitty happy life affirming advice can do more bad than good if its just thrown around with disregard, and if you are not in that position mentally to even want to accept that. Relatability and empathy is gold though, be it from friends or in here, which yeah this is a pertty good space for that <3