i like to cut for different reasons
1. as you said a punishment. most of the time i feel a division inside of me, where the *true* me and the me that i hate appear. so i just like to hurt and punish that other me for everything it had caused me to go through
2. again as you said the bleeding aspect! i find it fascinating watching the fresh cut fill up with blood and then start bleeding.. maybe smear the blood around my hands hahah thats weird sorry
3. idk if you or anyone can relate but i really like the feeling of hiding my cuts. like a have a secret that no one knows. it gives me some pride even maybe wandering around with cuts underneath my clothing, feeling like if i suddenly removed the layers and exposed the fresh wounds the unsespecting normies would freak out hahah just kidding, not normies but probably mentally healthy people soooo yeah those are the reasons for me, i feel like in some way they do coincide with yours!
I know this is a late reply but ive been off from this site for quite some time
Im really grateful for your insight on this matter and am quite surprised about how our views are similar, though mostly im interested in your first reason, the thought of feeling a division inside of yourself is interesting to me (although i dont relate to it)
(We both already know that we agree on the second point)
And as for your third point! You did make me realize something, besides the fact that ive always liked injuries, the thought of thinking of self harm as a secret that i can be 'proud of ' is something that resonates with me, I often fantasize about my self harm, how it makes me fell better and for some reason it also makes me fell better than others.
still although i am aware its not normal to feel this way I dont really care, but I am glad to find similar to me people.