'We'
'We' is often used when an individual feels part of a group, when their ideas have become aligned with people that they feel comfortable with. Its a sign of inclusion. For my part, I've never used the term to try and imply that my views are shared by the majority; if that is how it might come across then that bothers me. Actually, it appals me. I
never want people to think I'm trying to speak for anyone else.
I'd certainly never considered that and I can only re-state that my use of the term is intended as a way of including the tentative poster. 'We will listen' is somewhat more eloquent than 'there are people on here who will listen'. I'd certainly hope that in expressing any view its implicit that such a view is that of the individual, not the whole forum. Maybe I am wrong? Maybe I need to reconsider use of the term 'we'.
Bias
Is there a bias towards more established members? Mmmm… maybe, if so, then its an unconscious one, maybe based on the fact that people know them and their attitudes and its natural to listen to someone you know over someone you don't. That doesn't necessarily make it right though. I try to respond to anyone I connect with, regardless of how many posts they have made.
Cliques
Cliquish behaviour in a group is unfortunately natural and normal. It happens when members attitudes align. This can indeed exclude other but I've found that most people on ss are very receptive of anyone new, especially if they express any uncertainty at taking part. I've seen several threads that have expressed the fear of posting who have been encouraged and accepted and are now people whose posts and replies I read with interest.
Argument
I have seen very little toxic debate or manipulation here. I
have seen it though and its been shut down my the our moderators (sorry,
the moderators
). When I have seen disagreements, I've seen several instances where evidence has been put forward and opinions changed. That actually warms my heart. I've also seen instances where people agree to disagree and don't communicate any more. That's sad, but at least its respectful and realistic. That is also cool. I've actually not experienced such open minded and respectful behaviour on the internet before. Compare it to twitter and see the difference.
Influence
I think we all try to influence others to a certain extent. The very act of posting anything exerts an influence. Part of that may be couched in the need to control, something that we all have. Part of it is couched in the need to be controlled. For me, I like saying what I think and I enjoy having the way I think changed if people can give me a good enough reason to do that. I actually love having any entrenched attitudes I have challenged by solid evidence. I never want to be too certain of anything! Unfortunately, for me this often leads to me having conflicted views about things.
Language
The use of language in goodbye threads is really difficult for me. People do indeed mimic what others have been said, me included. But that's natural behaviour, especially when you don't know what to say. Anything I could say sounds trite, contrived and condescending to my ears. I don't want to passively encourage anyone to suicide by offering undue validation. I don't want to disrespect them by trying to talk them out of it if they are certain. I want to support them but I don't want to be condescending about such a serious and final act. Again, conflicted views. What do you say? If you found the perfect language, what then? Do you cut/paste the same response to every goodbye thread?
No way. So the clumsy language may seem insincere, but if the sentiment is true then sod how anyone else sees it as long as the poster feels supported but not encouraged.
I think that just the act of replying is something worthwhile in itself. I remember after my dad died and again after mum died, my colleagues were nervous about approaching me. The ones that did and offered their condolences, later confided in me that they didn't know what to say and that it felt like an empty sentiment. I replied honestly that it didn't matter, it was enough that they said something and didn't ignore me out of awkwardness. Ever after, I always made a point to offer condolences to the bereaved, no matter how awkward it felt. Did this make me feel better about myself for having done it? Yes, a little. Is that virtue signalling? Maybe, a little. Again, that's natural to an extent. Tough. The main thing was that the individual felt some support, empathy, compassion.
Likes farming
We all like to be liked. I'm guilty of this. If people like my posts then that makes me feel good. I like to see the notifications and often respond to them. Aren't we all guilty of this? Isn't this normal? Isn't that what social media is about to some extent? Seeking validation and worth? Okay, so if your intent is to actively farm likes then that's a bit odd and you may have a problem. Thing is, people on ss do have problems and sometimes do need validation.
Personally, I can barely leave the house cus I'm chained to the sodding toilet. This is the only social interaction I get. That's not ideal, but its something. If I can contribute in a small way then that gives me some small amount of worth that I don't get IRL. Is that selfish? Sure, a little. Tough! Is it wrong to feel good about yourself for offering support to someone or sharing your opinion and getting approval for it? No way. It doesn't invalidate any positive intention.
People have made some very interesting points which have made me think about my behaviour. I welcome that. And I've probably re-stated a lot of what's already been said in different language. Well, I wanted to get my thoughts across, even if it does re-state what's been said. I'm funny like that. I even sparked up the PC and did this reply in a WPS document so I could type properly instead of that awful predictive text.
But I wonder if we are over analysing a bit? None of us are perfect and we are all subject to behavioural tendencies. I think its important to be aware of these tendencies. Maybe that is the important thing rather than amending our behaviour to try and suit everyone.
Wow did you see how many times I used first person pronouns in that last bit? Now I'm seeing it everywhere.