I will tell you why reincarnation is false and stupid

[efil27]

I have seen people here being fearful of reincarnation so I would like to tell you why reincarnation is false
As someone born into a religion that has reincarnation as central pillar of it
1) if it was real you would have lived numerous previous life but you don't have any memory of even one now someone may say that you forgot your past memories as you grow up so my second point
2) have you seen all these reincarnation stories have a similarly if you guessed it it's the geographical boundary like if you ask an american person of his past life he will always say he was american or if you ask an European he will always say he was an European same way an Indian would always say he was an Indian in his past life
3)you will never hear someone born in america that he was an ainu( a tribe in japan) because he didn't even that exist reincarnation stories are based on the knowledge we had and until 100 years most people were geographically bound and didn't even know that others existed like my grandparents had no idea syria or Bulgaria existed and has their own unique cultures
To sum it up reincarnation stories existed as the same reason as religion the limited knowledge of our ancestors
HOPE IT HELPED

 

[Jack_Nimble]

Very interesting. I would love to hear someone try to counter that from the other perspective, belief in reincarnation.

Talking about past life stories being geographic. Reminds me of how NDE stories vary based on the culture the person lives in. And if the NDE story liners up with a religion it lines up with the religion that person was taught or whatever the major religion is in their country.

So many people of different religions claim their NDE confirms their religion. Bunch of bologna. Interesting bologna but still bologna.

 

[Haibane-renmei-reki]

I have seen people here being fearful of reincarnation so I would like to tell you why reincarnation is false
As someone born into a religion that has reincarnation as central pillar of it
1) if it was real you would have lived numerous previous life but you don't have any memory of even one now someone may say that you forgot your past memories as you grow up so my second point
2) have you seen all these reincarnation stories have a similarly if you guessed it it's the geographical boundary like if you ask an american person of his past life he will always say he was american or if you ask an European he will always say he was an European same way an Indian would always say he was an Indian in his past life
3)you will never hear someone born in america that he was an ainu( a tribe in japan) because he didn't even that exist reincarnation stories are based on the knowledge we had and until 100 years most people were geographically bound and didn't even know that others existed like my grandparents had no idea syria or Bulgaria existed and has their own unique cultures
To sum it up reincarnation stories existed as the same reason as religion the limited knowledge of our ancestors
HOPE IT HELPED

thanks for the insightful post

 

[taylorj]

I've actually heard multiple claims of American people remembering being, for example, a Jew in a concentration camp in a past life.... There's also plenty of examples online of young people who somehow know foreign languages or know how to play an instrument that they shouldn't. I'm not going to confirm or deny my belief.... Reincarnation certainly isn't a religious idea that I grew up with as an American but it is one that makes the most sense to me. I'm also open to the possibility of continuing progression in the afterlife...like the soul continuing to learn lessons and progress after death. I don't think it makes any sense that when you die you're just dead and that's just it. Although that would be comforting in a sense.

 

[froggirl9000]

 

[efil27]

I've actually heard multiple claims of American people remembering being, for example, a Jew in a concentration camp in a past life.... There's also plenty of examples online of young people who somehow know foreign languages or know how to play an instrument that they shouldn't. I'm not going to confirm or deny my belief.... Reincarnation certainly isn't a religious idea that I grew up with as an American but it is one that makes the most sense to me. I'm also open to the possibility of continuing progression in the afterlife...like the soul continuing to learn lessons and progress after death. I don't think it makes any sense that when you die you're just dead and that's just it. Although that would be comforting in a sense.

But why is he is always a jew in Germany or Europe but not from Israel or other places where hitler didn't captured

View attachment 171710

No you are misunderstanding life may go on forever as new universes get created and destroyed but the unique consciousness of you ie your unique born will never existed once you die you are a unique pattern of information created by your brain once it dies the the unique you cease to exist time or entropy may go on but there would no you to experience it

 

[Infinitespace_]

I have seen people here being fearful of reincarnation so I would like to tell you why reincarnation is false
As someone born into a religion that has reincarnation as central pillar of it
1) if it was real you would have lived numerous previous life but you don't have any memory of even one now someone may say that you forgot your past memories as you grow up so my second point
2) have you seen all these reincarnation stories have a similarly if you guessed it it's the geographical boundary like if you ask an american person of his past life he will always say he was american or if you ask an European he will always say he was an European same way an Indian would always say he was an Indian in his past life
3)you will never hear someone born in america that he was an ainu( a tribe in japan) because he didn't even that exist reincarnation stories are based on the knowledge we had and until 100 years most people were geographically bound and didn't even know that others existed like my grandparents had no idea syria or Bulgaria existed and has their own unique cultures
To sum it up reincarnation stories existed as the same reason as religion the limited knowledge of our ancestors
HOPE IT HELPED

The reason you don't remember your past life is because you die in unconsciousness and you are born in unconsciousness, just as you don't remember being born, you were told you were born on such a day. the geographical boundary is based on, where you die you are born, you will find the nearest womb that fits with you and enter there so its very likely that if you die in India you will be born in India.

there have been many stories of children remembering their past lives with great accuracy which cannot be explained

 

[efil27]

The reason you don't remember your past life is because you die in unconsciousness and you are born in unconsciousness, just as you don't remember being born, you were told you were born on such a day. the geographical boundary is based on, where you die you are born, you will find the nearest womb that fits with you and enter there so its very likely that if you die in India you will be born in India.

there have been many stories of children remembering their past lives with great accuracy which cannot be explained

Logistics problem for the soul lol no reincarnation is impossible there is no soul to reincarnate we are just patterns generated by the brain read science not pseudoscience

 

[Infinitespace_]

Logistics problem for the soul lol no reincarnation is impossible there is no soul to reincarnate we are just patterns generated by the brain read science not pseudoscience

Science does not fully understand or know what consciousness even is.

 

[pthnrdnojvsc]

Logistics problem for the soul lol no reincarnation is impossible there is no soul to reincarnate we are just patterns generated by the brain read science not pseudoscience

I agree. a human is just a brain.

1. where is the energy source for a soul?

2. where do souls go?

3. why are souls hiding ? why is there no evidence? billions have video cameras on phones , there have been many technical instruments yet none have ever detected any soul nor energy source for a soul reincarnation , afterlife , god , anything supernatural, multi-verses, other dimensions, computer simulation. .....nothing no evidence for any of that

83% of population believe there is a soul. i don't and never will . just one example this evil world is full of lies.

 

[badatparties]

I don't think there's any evidence of it aside from a small amount of NDE's. NDE's also vary so much from individual to individual that there is no consensus on what fucking happens. Sometimes Christians will see Jesus and stuff but the majority never do. There are some commonalities between a lot of NDE's such as a tunnel, floating above the body, a feeling of being at home or at peace, encountering dead relatives, and life review. There doesn't seem to be a lot of evidence for reincarnation though.

Also, true brain death is irreversible, so it's very likely that people going through a "near death experience" have a firing brain. All brain activity doesn't automatically cease after the heart stops. You will be completely unconscious, but irreversible brain death takes a while.

 

[kopebaldy]

The fact that my next life will be worse thanks to all the bad karma I accumulate in this one is a stupid system.

I'm sorry it's not bad enough NOW? Hello god, I ain't playing this stupid game on ultra hard mode mate.

Balance your shit.

 

[Nightfoot]

It's interesting to speculate, but I just can't see the likelihood that reincarnation exists.

 

[Infinitespace_]

The fact that my next life will be worse thanks to all the bad karma I accumulate in this one is a stupid system.

I'm sorry it's not bad enough NOW? Hello god, I ain't playing this stupid game on ultra hard mode mate.

Balance your shit.

I don't think there is a law of karma its just a human invention to think that doing good deeds will mean your next life will be better. when you do some action, The cause and effect Is immediate there is not need to wait until the next life to be rewarded or punished...

It's interesting to speculate, but I just can't see the likelihood that reincarnation exists.

why not, nothing in the physical world can be destroyed not even a drop of water... what about the inner world?

 

[knickknack81]

Well no one really knows what happens to us after we die so it's probably not even worth wasting yr energy on. Life at the current moment has so many issues its probably best to just focus on that. Even though it can be interesting/fun to think about the possibility of reincarnation or heaven/hell/purgatory, no one knows for sure. Then again, im also not a very religious/spiritual person so that probably takes into account the lack of interest in my part. As long as it ends the pain and suffering this current life is giving me, then that's I care about.

 

[akiyama346]

There's no evidence for anything metaphysical tbqh. But if someone really finds comfort in reincarnation, heaven, or anything else, then they should hold onto that. People should hold onto things that make life easier. If you believe in heaven, then let it exist. It doesn't matter so much anyways, for most of history and future we are dead and we are alive for a very small sliver of time.

In my opinion out of all of the metaphysical and religious stuff, reincarnation makes the most sense. Consider a "horrible person" like a murderer or a sexual predator or somebody like that, they're not born that way, nor did they really make the choice to become that person. They are tossed down that narrow life path leading to the decisions they made, they never grow up the same way as normal people. Whether that's exposure to violence at an early age, being preyed on, etc. They were victimized at some point, and through various factors they ended up the person they are (look up determinism). So this is why I don't understand the concept of heaven and hell, it doesn't seem fair for this all-knowing God to do this. To subject someone to the emotional and socioeconomic circumstances to be a thief, a killer, or something else, and them punish for all of eternity based on their circumstantial actions during a short 50-80 years of life. It makes more sense for someone to go through various cycles of reincarnation, being tried over and over again, until reaching "samsara".

 

[Infinitespace_]

But if someone really finds comfort in reincarnation, heaven, or anything else, then they should hold onto that. People should hold onto things that make life easier. If you believe in heaven, then let it exist.

Belief is a tranquilizer for the mind. It gives you the illusion of knowing. A believer clings to borrowed truths — secondhand ideas from scriptures and priests. Heaven, reincarnation — these are sweet dreams to keep you asleep

 

[Parnate]

I believe in God or whatever force that is out there. I believe that God or that force is just. So many nice and kind people suffer , their suffering and pain seems very unjustified and unfair since in this life they have been so nice and good. So if they are suffering their has to be a reason for that and that is the previous life karma.

 

[Infinitespace_]

I believe in God or whatever force that is out there. I believe that God or that force is just. So many nice and kind people suffer , their suffering and pain seems very unjustified and unfair since in this life they have been so nice and good. So if they are suffering their has to be a reason for that and that is the previous life karma.

so we shouldn't help them either because they need to suffer that because of previous life karma