• ⚠️ UK Access Block Notice: Beginning July 1, 2025, this site will no longer be accessible from the United Kingdom. This is a voluntary decision made by the site's administrators. We were not forced or ordered to implement this block. If you're located in the UK, we recommend using a VPN to maintain access.

S

Scythe

Lost in a delusion
Sep 5, 2022
612
There's a book out there called the ones who walk away from Omelas, I'm using it as my main point though I haven't read it because my brain's too impaired for reading most days now.

For those of you who don't know, the Ones who walk away from Omelas is basically about a utopia where everyone is happy and resources are plentiful. However, this utopia is built on a single child's suffering. No one knows why the chils needs to suffer but everyone will eventually know about the price of their utopia at some point once they're old enough. Then they are offered a choice, to stay or leave. Most stay, because the suffering of a single child for a near prefect world seems a good tradeoff. But sometimes, someone will walk away.

And I think this book can be used as a metaphor for us, at least the ppl here that hate society. Heck we don't even live in a utopia. We cannot see the good in the world as a worthy tradeoff to the bad, so we're walking away, and because there is no land outside of our "Omelas" we choose death.
(Technically there's the option of living in the woods but that's a death sentence to most people anyways.)

And like how it's done in the book, our choices should be respected, we should have the option to "walk away". I think this entire thing is also kind of unrelated to the book's message? But I still feel it can be used to explain our views.
 
  • Like
Reactions: thelastmessiah and pthnrdnojvsc
A

alwaysalone

Student
May 14, 2025
188
There's a book out there called the ones who walk away from Omelas, I'm using it as my main point though I haven't read it because my brain's too impaired for reading most days now.

For those of you who don't know, the Ones who walk away from Omelas is basically about a utopia where everyone is happy and resources are plentiful. However, this utopia is built on a single child's suffering. No one knows why the chils needs to suffer but everyone will eventually know about the price of their utopia at some point once they're old enough. Then they are offered a choice, to stay or leave. Most stay, because the suffering of a single child for a near prefect world seems a good tradeoff. But sometimes, someone will walk away.

And I think this book can be used as a metaphor for us, at least the ppl here that hate society. Heck we don't even live in a utopia. We cannot see the good in the world as a worthy tradeoff to the bad, so we're walking away, and because there is no land outside of our "Omelas" we choose death.
(Technically there's the option of living in the woods but that's a death sentence to most people anyways.)

And like how it's done in the book, our choices should be respected, we should have the option to "walk away". I think this entire thing is also kind of unrelated to the book's message? But I still feel it can be used to explain our views.
I've read that story it's good and your comparison makes a lot of sense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scythe
Apathy79

Apathy79

Elementalist
Oct 13, 2019
833
I'm intrigued if by walking away you can save the child? Then it's a test of character. If not, I don't understand why you would walk away.
 
A

alwaysalone

Student
May 14, 2025
188
I'm intrigued if by walking away you can save the child? Then it's a test of character. If not, I don't understand why you would walk away.
No it doesn't save the child. They walk away because they can't live with the idea their happiness is bought and paid for by an innocent child's suffering.
 
S

Scythe

Lost in a delusion
Sep 5, 2022
612
I'm intrigued if by walking away you can save the child? Then it's a test of character. If not, I don't understand why you would walk away.
They can't save the child, but one interpretation I've heard is that they go on to create a truly prefect utopia with no need for a suffering child.