I posted something pretty similar in the "Appreciation for the mods" thread. You're so right, and it's so true.
Here's what I don't understand.
Suicide can definitely be a rational choice, but pretend for a minute you're one of the majority of people who disagree. In their perspective suicide is a psychological problem similar to alcoholism or drug addiction, but it's treated totally differently.
What I mean is, when people are alcoholics, addicted to gambling, etc. the response isn't to just yell at them and say "DRINKING IS NEVER THE ANSWER NEVER DRINK HOW COULD YOU EVEN THINK OF DRINKING" or lock them up in a hospital like people do with suicidal people. You have a reasonable discussion about it, and maybe even join something like alcoholics anonymous. That's how you treat it. And that's what we're doing here with suicide. It's like alcoholics anonymous for suicide, and if we could have something similar in real life I think suicide rates would go down.
Society is so hung up on stopping people from killing themselves at all costs that it's created a stigma which is causing more people to kill themselves because if they talk about they are treated like lepers.
It makes me pretty angry.