D

Disaster

Experienced
Jan 24, 2023
291
This short story by Ursula Le Guin deeply resonates with my soul:
I think we, suicidal people, are the "miserable child" for our real societies. I mean of course there's not much prosperity and happiness around and all even for non-suicidal ones, but torturing us (incarcerating "for our own good" etc.) serves a similar purpose of ensuring status quo.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: sserafim, Homo erectus, charlotte_ and 4 others
TransilvanianHunger

TransilvanianHunger

Grave with a view...
Jan 22, 2023
358
Omelas is my favourite Le Guin short story, and one of my favourite works of literature in general.

I wouldn't say that suicidal people are like the child in the story because the child's suffering was what made the idyllic life of everyone else in Omelas possible. Abhorrent as the child's situation was, it had a purpose. The child suffered horribly so that everyone else could be happy. Of course, this arrangement was so horrifying to some that they preferred to walk away from their blessed life in Omelas. In the real world, suffering is overwhelmingly useless.

But I see a similarity with our real societies—in Omelas, like in the real world, the vast majority of people prefer to ignore the unimaginable suffering that some people deal with every day, because acknowledging it would make their own lives unbearable; allowing themselves to recognise the injustice would force them to confront their own moral failings. It's easier and more comfortable to turn a blind eye towards suffering, and carry on with your own affairs. Suicidal people are kept in check, so to speak, because acknowledging their very real suffering would force us to look in the mirror and deal with our moral failings. It's easier to lock suicidal people up, or tell them to hit the gym and take a walk every day. In that sense, we are very much like the people of Omelas.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sserafim, Ontwon, Per Ardua Ad Astra and 1 other person
buyersremorse

buyersremorse

useless
Feb 16, 2023
64
I feel like we're more like the ones who walk away than the child.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sserafim, Aergia and Ontwon
F

free_at_last

'Dying ain't much of a living, son' - Josey Wales
May 27, 2023
6
I can't believe I'm reading a thread about Omelas. Isn't it odd that the reference is to Salem, Oregon, which now, many years later, has become the spearhead for VAD.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Per Ardua Ad Astra
sserafim

sserafim

brighter than the sun, that’s just me
Sep 13, 2023
9,013
I should have the right to walk away
 
  • Like
Reactions: ijustwishtodie and Rocinante

Similar threads

tvo
Replies
54
Views
5K
Suicide Discussion
Depressed2
D
Octavia
Replies
29
Views
4K
Suicide Discussion
vanillamilkshakes
vanillamilkshakes