Is table salt supposed to be similar at all to drinking sodium nitrite?
I respectfully advise you read this detailed journal and other success/failure accounts to determine for yourself.
What's your reasoning for thinking Nitschke peddles disinformation?
This is my reasoning:
• Unlike medical documents, the PPH does not reference other sources to support his claims. His authority is that he is a doctor, but he does not "stand on the shoulders of
giants" to validate his advice and claims, he is the giant. The claim of authority, such as that of a doctor, is a common manipulative advertising practice of persuasion to trust in a product or its producer.
• He suggests specific Latin American veterinary supply resources (not A, but shops) for N but does not update the guide when they are no longer good sources. This creates unfulfillable hope, expensive trips, and extraordinary efforts based on trust. Updating the info in updates would do much to prove a desire to be worthy of and earn trust as an authority.
• He does not document the reasons for rating any method as peaceful, reliable, etc., and the ratings and methods change with updates, leading to confusion, which makes one more easy to manipulate.
• He makes the PPH desirable by limiting access to it. Scarcity increases desire, which overrides critical thinking and suspicion. Desperation for a means of peaceful exit also overrides critical thinking and suspicion, which the scarcity increases. Scarcity is a common manipulative advertising practice of persuasion.
• He dangles the carrot of the debreather, but postpones its release after setting expectations of availability by publishing release dates. This is another example of scarcity.
• All good disinformation has some truth, otherwise no one would listen.
• I do not have to know the purpose of manipulation, only to recognize it. There is no burden of proof on me to find a notice in order to justify my assertion; the burden of proof is on him to prove worthy of trust in following his guidance. Based on his actions, and my understanding of manipulation and disinformation, I am confident that he is unworthy of trust. Others can disagree and I have no problem with that.
These are just some of my reasons. There is a thread titled Manipulation Tactics in Off Topic if you have a desire to educate yourself about them. There are multiple documented sources on the thread.
I do not seek to convince you, only to answer your question, which my assertion in the OP led you to ask, so it is relevant to the thread. However if you desire to discuss this further or to open a debate, I respectfully ask that you create a new thread. I do not wish to see this thread derailed as it has a very clear and specific purpose -- journaling my practice and preparation for my potential use of the SN method, and engaging in dialogue about it for my benefit and others'. Based on your questions on the other thread, and your using the link to this one, I hope you find benefit here, but if not, it's all good.