I would think that what unifies us here in SaSu is a mutual desire to support each other in a manner that the person wants.
I believe that is a very fine line here. Supporting each other does sometimes mean saying what a person
needs, not necessarily
wants to hear. For example, if someone here would discuss a ctb method that has a high risk of failure, I think we all agree that such a person needs advice to reconsider this attempt.
Talking someone out of his suicidal attempt is a bit more of an edge case, especially when it's based on platitudes. That's what suicide prevention hotlines are for, but not this forum.
I don't think this should be a place to neglect someone's experiences or world views. On the other hand, having someone open a positive perspective can brighten the day, and that – always assuming people act with the best of their intentions – is something I guess
@TheSadStranger wanted to do here.
I personally would put it this way:
1. If you don't know what's causing your pain, find out
2. If you have found out, try to dream about your life. Don't be realistic. Just dream
3. See what's preventing you from achieving that dream and assess if there is a glimpse of a hope
You can "fail" at any of these three steps. Sometimes, it's mindset and sometimes it's hard facts that renders your life to a pointless existence. If it is the former, you have a chance to take action.
It is worth going that path – not because life is a gift – but because you will find relief. Either by having tried and recovered – or by strengthening your determination to ctb.