help me pick which is best

[lovedread]

Theme is enchanted forest. Yall gotta help me im losing my fucking mind over this shit

 

[wCvML2]

This is a really complicated design, is this going to be made irl? I like the first design because of how the branches surrounding the base have the same arch like the flower beside it and it also has a hedgehog sitting on top but all of the designs look great.

 

[Rocinante]

2 looks nice

 

[eatantz]

OMG CAKE OFF!!!!! this is beautiful, i love sweating in cake off. They all look so good 3 is my fav

 

[ijustwishtodie]

I think that two is best but all of them are definitely far better than what I could make. Your skills are truly exceptional. I'm in complete envy

 

[eatantz]

omg what's your level? people in the pro lobby's never do this good i wish i could see all your cakesss

 

[Mizzlizzy]

all look good can't decide lol

 

[-Link-]

I think the second one is too busy (for lack of a better word) and that the third one could look a little livelier.

The first one, I think, has more of an elegance to it compared to the other two.

So I'd pick the first one.

 

[lovedread]

omg what's your level? people in the pro lobby's never do this good i wish i could see all your cakesss

Plsss i could never make this in a pro lobby it took hours ty tho im like level 34

This is a really complicated design, is this going to be made irl? I like the first design because of how the branches surrounding the base have the same arch like the flower beside it and it also has a hedgehog sitting on top but all of the designs look great.

No its for a digital competition! Thx for your feedback

 

[-Link-]

No its for a digital competition!

Hmm... If it's supposed to look like "what an actual cake could be", then I might have to change my pick to the second one...

I think:

- The first one looks best suited as "something that belongs in an enchanted forest"
- The second one looks best suited as "something that can actually be made into a cake"
- The third one could work as well, but only if the forest is of a darker nature

For any baker who can actually make something like these... I bow down to them in awe of their cake-making skills.