TAW122
Emissary of the right to die.
- Aug 30, 2018
- 6,826
So I know lately I've been having a lot of rants and vents in regards to the mental health system (in the US and even around the world), but when I have interesting perspectives and insights, I can't help but to share them. I believe it may benefit some others who have experienced similar encounters and/or be another example of how useless the system is for a lot of people.
As someone who is really black and white when it comes to logic, analytical, and more of a problem solver type (or whatever personality you call it), I don't respond well to talk therapy. I can briefly explain why it doesn't work, but first, I will explain what happens during talk therapy with most therapists and most counseling (again not all therapists or MHPs are like this but a majority of them are). So what happens is a patient goes in to talk about their life, their issues, problems, and what not, then at first the therapist/counselor/MHP sits there and nods and (pretends to) listens to what the patient has to say. Then he/she asks a question, usually just reflecting and rehashing the feelings that the patient described. A common one is "How does that make you feel?" and other questions include but aren't limited to (and wording can vary too) "What would you do if you could get x (where x is what you wanted)?", "If you could do xyz (where xyz is what you wanted), how would you feel?", "What are your plans on getting it, how would you go about it? (which is an insulting question as it is boomeranging what the patient asked.)" and many more. This is the same pattern with just about all the MHPs I've encountered in my life, but with subtle variations, some will suggest inane shit like writing down a list of interests and other general boiler, stock advice, which doesn't work to solve whatever problem I'm seeking to solve. Also, don't forget about the gaslighting and shame for wrongthink, saying the wrong thing (not politically correct or what society deems abnormal). In another thread, I did mention that MHPs are not looking to solve your problems or find solutions but to get you to be a functioning member of society again and re-indoctrinate you into mass groupthink that society has. They don't care about your woes and suffering as long as you aren't a danger to yourself or others.
So in summary talk therapy is useless because the therapist, counselor, MHPs aren't really interested or listening to your problems let alone looking for a solution, but are just seeking out a pattern and looking for behaviors to "diagnose" you, "parse" through what you said until the end just to throw some inane advice or non-solution, and of course "fishing" for keywords, red flags and looking for that opening to take action against you (including threat assessment and even potentially involuntary holds, psych holds, and what not). That's really what they are there for most of the time. In the case of the rare gem that does listen and have compassion for you, well even then, he/she may or may not help with your problems and of course are still bound by mandated reporting guidelines and what not, so I wouldn't even get comfortable during an encounter with them.
As someone who is really black and white when it comes to logic, analytical, and more of a problem solver type (or whatever personality you call it), I don't respond well to talk therapy. I can briefly explain why it doesn't work, but first, I will explain what happens during talk therapy with most therapists and most counseling (again not all therapists or MHPs are like this but a majority of them are). So what happens is a patient goes in to talk about their life, their issues, problems, and what not, then at first the therapist/counselor/MHP sits there and nods and (pretends to) listens to what the patient has to say. Then he/she asks a question, usually just reflecting and rehashing the feelings that the patient described. A common one is "How does that make you feel?" and other questions include but aren't limited to (and wording can vary too) "What would you do if you could get x (where x is what you wanted)?", "If you could do xyz (where xyz is what you wanted), how would you feel?", "What are your plans on getting it, how would you go about it? (which is an insulting question as it is boomeranging what the patient asked.)" and many more. This is the same pattern with just about all the MHPs I've encountered in my life, but with subtle variations, some will suggest inane shit like writing down a list of interests and other general boiler, stock advice, which doesn't work to solve whatever problem I'm seeking to solve. Also, don't forget about the gaslighting and shame for wrongthink, saying the wrong thing (not politically correct or what society deems abnormal). In another thread, I did mention that MHPs are not looking to solve your problems or find solutions but to get you to be a functioning member of society again and re-indoctrinate you into mass groupthink that society has. They don't care about your woes and suffering as long as you aren't a danger to yourself or others.
So in summary talk therapy is useless because the therapist, counselor, MHPs aren't really interested or listening to your problems let alone looking for a solution, but are just seeking out a pattern and looking for behaviors to "diagnose" you, "parse" through what you said until the end just to throw some inane advice or non-solution, and of course "fishing" for keywords, red flags and looking for that opening to take action against you (including threat assessment and even potentially involuntary holds, psych holds, and what not). That's really what they are there for most of the time. In the case of the rare gem that does listen and have compassion for you, well even then, he/she may or may not help with your problems and of course are still bound by mandated reporting guidelines and what not, so I wouldn't even get comfortable during an encounter with them.
Last edited: