nzdarkshark

nzdarkshark

The Loved Mistake
Sep 4, 2018
400
If I were to say, jump off a 36 metre tall grain silo onto gravely ground, what would likely happen to my body? Would it be likely I'd die on impact? Would it be messy?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Baskol1
A

AShadowOnMe

Member
Aug 19, 2019
14
It sounds like you're in the grey area of 'Probably but it's not 100%'. Making sure you go headfirst would increase the chances immensely as well as likelihood of instant unconsciousness.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Baskol1 and nzdarkshark
nzdarkshark

nzdarkshark

The Loved Mistake
Sep 4, 2018
400
If it's any help, I'm around 4'5 in height and weigh around 42-45kgs
 
  • Like
Reactions: Baskol1
Baskol1

Baskol1

No life, no problems
Aug 11, 2019
1,030
Its probably deadly but not guaranteed, there is a slight chance to survive it. But that would be very unlikely.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AShadowOnMe and nzdarkshark
Lookingforabus

Lookingforabus

Arcanist
Aug 6, 2019
421
It wouldn't be likely to kill you on impact, no. You might get lucky, but most likely you'd either die slowly from internal injuries and blood loss, or get saved with serious injuries, depending on how quickly someone finds you.

As to messy... Depends on your definition. Jumping isn't usually overly messy (like spray bits of skull and brain matter about with a gunshot to the head), but you're talking about a pool of blood and a generally unpleasant looking body.

The sources I've read say that suicide by jumping should be highly lethal at 50 meters and up onto hard ground... so 36 meters seems like it falls into that risky category. I'd be very worried about surviving with serious injuries, and would find a different location or method.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Baskol1
nzdarkshark

nzdarkshark

The Loved Mistake
Sep 4, 2018
400
It wouldn't be likely to kill you on impact, no. You might get lucky, but most likely you'd either die slowly from internal injuries and blood loss, or get saved with serious injuries, depending on how quickly someone finds you.

As to messy... Depends on your definition. Jumping isn't usually overly messy (like spray bits of skull and brain matter about with a gunshot to the head), but you're talking about a pool of blood and a generally unpleasant looking body.

The sources I've read say that suicide by jumping should be highly lethal at 50 meters and up onto hard ground... so 36 meters seems like it falls into that risky category. I'd be very worried about surviving with serious injuries, and would find a different location or method.
It's just that that's the highest thing in this place - and most other methods are unavailable to me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Baskol1
Baskol1

Baskol1

No life, no problems
Aug 11, 2019
1,030
It wouldn't be likely to kill you on impact, no. You might get lucky, but most likely you'd either die slowly from internal injuries and blood loss, or get saved with serious injuries, depending on how quickly someone finds you.

As to messy... Depends on your definition. Jumping isn't usually overly messy (like spray bits of skull and brain matter about with a gunshot to the head), but you're talking about a pool of blood and a generally unpleasant looking body.

The sources I've read say that suicide by jumping should be highly lethal at 50 meters and up onto hard ground... so 36 meters seems like it falls into that risky category. I'd be very worried about surviving with serious injuries, and would find a different location or method.

I think 36 meters is in the most cases enough to die. But yes there is a small risk. There are even some few people who survived more than 100 meters, but extremely unlikely.
 
Lookingforabus

Lookingforabus

Arcanist
Aug 6, 2019
421
It's just that that's the highest thing in this place - and most other methods are unavailable to me.

To each their own. I'd pick hanging over a fall that might not be fatal, but it's not my call. I guess landing head first and definitely not feet first would be the best advice if you're dead set on jumping from this location.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nzdarkshark and Baskol1
nzdarkshark

nzdarkshark

The Loved Mistake
Sep 4, 2018
400
To each their own. I'd pick hanging over a fall that might not be fatal, but it's not my call. I guess landing head first and definitely not feet first would be the best advice if you're dead set on jumping from this location.
I just don't know. I also have a fear of heights which could make the chance of survival higher. I've been struggling to be able to close the Carotid arteries in practise. This is a nightmare.
 
  • Like
  • Hugs
Reactions: woxihuanni, WatermelonMel and Baskol1
A

Amz_Falls

Student
Aug 23, 2019
175
I jumped, only 25m though so you might get luckier than me. You go bang and crunch and destroy your body.
 
  • Hugs
  • Like
Reactions: Quinlor and Baskol1
Soul

Soul

gate gate paragate parasamgate bodhi svaha
Apr 12, 2019
4,704
It's just that that's the highest thing in this place - and most other methods are unavailable to me.

@nzdarkshark, can you get to another location somehow, with some effort & planning? And when you say "most other methods are unavailable", which options *are* available? Because jumping from an iffy height isn't very sensible.

I'm sorry about everything that's led you to contemplating this. x
 
  • Like
Reactions: Baskol1
nzdarkshark

nzdarkshark

The Loved Mistake
Sep 4, 2018
400
@nzdarkshark, can you get to another location somehow, with some effort & planning? And when you say "most other methods are unavailable", which options *are* available? Because jumping from an iffy height isn't very sensible.

I'm sorry about everything that's led you to contemplating this. x

My only options really are suspension (most likely partial) or jumping from the silo. I can't receive packages because I live with my parents and I cannot drive.
I guess I could get hit by a truck - but I don't want to involve innocent people if I can help it.
 
  • Love
  • Like
Reactions: Soul and Baskol1
Baskol1

Baskol1

No life, no problems
Aug 11, 2019
1,030
My only options really are suspension (most likely partial) or jumping from the silo. I can't receive packages because I live with my parents and I cannot drive.
I guess I could get hit by a truck - but I don't want to involve innocent people if I can help it.

Yeah, no dont drag innnocents into your suicide, it would traumatize them, and many trauma survivors commit suicide too. So thats bad. My philosophy is everything that increases suffering is immoral.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nzdarkshark
Soul

Soul

gate gate paragate parasamgate bodhi svaha
Apr 12, 2019
4,704
Would CO with charcoal be possible? It seems better than jumping from something not quite high enough to definitely kill you.
 
nzdarkshark

nzdarkshark

The Loved Mistake
Sep 4, 2018
400
Would CO with charcoal be possible? It seems better than jumping from something not quite high enough to definitely kill you.
I don't know how I could get it..
Is there a megathread on that method I could give a read? I'm literally so lost and feel so pathetic that I'll look into any method (that doesn't involve others).
 
  • Hugs
Reactions: Soul
Soul

Soul

gate gate paragate parasamgate bodhi svaha
Apr 12, 2019
4,704
(((Hugs)))

There are several threads about charcoal - I hope this link will take you to my search results:
https://sanctioned-suicide.net/search/115947/?q=Charcoal&o=relevance

It's not the easiest method to get right, but if you can get Asian charcoal that seems to work better than European or American kinds. It's not expensive, so maybe you can buy it casually for your newfound interest in barbeque grilling or clam baking or something.

You do need a small space that's separate from where anyone else could get overcome by it, but it's worth looking into.

Be gentle with yourself. I'm sorry you're contemplating this and that you feel lost. x
 
  • Like
Reactions: nzdarkshark
nzdarkshark

nzdarkshark

The Loved Mistake
Sep 4, 2018
400
(((Hugs)))

There are several threads about charcoal - I hope this link will take you to my search results:
https://sanctioned-suicide.net/search/115947/?q=Charcoal&o=relevance

It's not the easiest method to get right, but if you can get Asian charcoal that seems to work better than European or American kinds. It's not expensive, so maybe you can buy it casually for your newfound interest in barbeque grilling or clam baking or something.

You do need a small space that's separate from where anyone else could get overcome by it, but it's worth looking into.

Be gentle with yourself. I'm sorry you're contemplating this and that you feel lost. x
I'll look into it - I just don't know how I can get my hands on charcoal and heat it without my parents getting suspisious. I don't know where I would do it either - unless I somehow got into the small shed out back and taped the door (which has a hole in it).
 
  • Hugs
Reactions: Soul

Similar threads

Q
Replies
6
Views
268
Suicide Discussion
canijo
canijo
dust-in-the-wind
Replies
1
Views
229
Suicide Discussion
mango-meridian
mango-meridian
C
Replies
3
Views
125
Suicide Discussion
FlufflesAway
FlufflesAway
AboutTimeToDepart
Replies
5
Views
393
Suicide Discussion
athiestjoe
athiestjoe
Kadaver
Replies
0
Views
63
Suicide Discussion
Kadaver
Kadaver