Suitable helium tank for inert gas method?

[Eleanor]

I'm looking for a helium tank for the inert gas method. Would this one be okay? I would buy two of them, as described in the book Dignified Dying:

Size tank: 13 liters
Quality: 99.99% pure helium
Amount of helium: 0.40m3 gas / 512.9 liters helium
Weight: 4.24 kilograms
Size: 25 x 25 x 38cm

I hope there's someone here who can help me with this. Thanks for reading and I hope you are doing at least reasonably well.

 

[MyChoiceAlone]

i think you're better off going with nitrogen. i heard it's hard to get helium that pure anymore.

 

[befree]

The purity is ok. But the size depends on the inert gas method: SCUBA, SCBA, EEBG hood, exit bag.

 

[Eleanor]

i think you're better off going with nitrogen. i heard it's hard to get helium that pure anymore.

I can just order a helium tank with 99 to 99.99% purity. They are not hard to find where I live.

The purity is ok. But the size depends on the inert gas method: SCUBA, SCBA, EEBG hood, exit bag.

I'm using an exit bag. Do you think it would be enough to have 800-1000 liters helium?

 

[befree]

Better ask this question here:

Exit bag and inert gas megathread

Hi all, I'm hoping you guys could help me with this. I'm looking for a helium tank for the inert gas method. Would this one be okay? I would buy two of them, as described in the book Dignified Dying. They are readily available in my country so that's not an issue: Size tank: 13 liters Quality...

sanctioned-suicide.net

 

[GasMonkey]

At 15 LPM that would be 34 minutes.

 

[AresCohere]

Helium is too light and expensive to be worth using, it will likely escape and/or just float up to the top of whatever "chamber" is being used.

 

[befree]

"chamber"

The "chambers" are: SCUBA, SCBA, EEBD hood, exit bag, Rebreather. Please use the search function and inform yourself before you write wrong information.

 

[Eleanor]

Helium is too light and expensive to be worth using, it will likely escape and/or just float up to the top of whatever "chamber" is being used

How do mean it will likely escape or float to the top? Helium is listed as a succesful method in both the book I've read and the PPH.

How much do you think it would cost to buy enough helium? I calculated it would cost me around €100 - €120 to buy around 1000 liters helium, but I'm not sure whether the tanks I've looked up are the correct ones.

 

[AresCohere]

How do mean it will likely escape or float to the top? Helium is listed as a succesful method in both the book I've read and the PPH.

How much do you think it would cost to buy enough helium? I calculated it would cost me around €100 - €120 to buy around 1000 liters helium, but I'm not sure whether the tanks I've looked up are the correct ones.

Helium is a fairly light element and if not enough is used or if it isn't sealed enough it can easily escape, hence why nitrogen, a gas with the same density as air, is much more usable.

The "chambers" are: SCUBA, SCBA, EEBD hood, exit bag, Rebreather. Please use the search function and inform yourself before you write wrong information.

Used "chambers" (in quotes) to refenence any hardware used, not a real chamber.

 

[depressedteddybear]

I'm looking for a helium tank for the inert gas method. Would this one be okay? I would buy two of them, as described in the book Dignified Dying:

Size tank: 13 liters
Quality: 99.99% pure helium
Amount of helium: 0.40m3 gas / 512.9 liters helium
Weight: 4.24 kilograms
Size: 25 x 25 x 38cm

I hope there's someone here who can help me with this. Thanks for reading and I hope you are doing at least reasonably well.

Use nitrogen or argon u can get extremely pure argon at any welding supply store without raising suspension just tell them u just got a tig machine and need a bottle

 

[GasMonkey]

Helium is too light and expensive to be worth using

Helium was used for decades for CTBing with the ExitBag, it's an amazing gas for the bag because it has a huge weight difference with CO₂. It has indeed become expensive because the supply is dwindling since it cannot be manufactured.​

just float up to the top of whatever "chamber" is being used

That's really good because the CO₂ gets pushed downwards and purged.

hence why nitrogen, a gas with the same density as air, is much more usable.

The main reason why Nitrogen is the most common CTB gas nowadays is because the Balloon Helium tanks are mixed with Air these days, not due to some supposed better performance of Nitrogen for CTBing. For demand valve setups (SCUBA/SCBA) Nitrogen is usually the way to go since those valves are mostly used with Air which has virtually the same weight.​

if it isn't sealed enough it can easily escape

In an ExitBag gas is always escaping for CO₂ purging.

Use nitrogen or argon u can get extremely pure argon at any welding supply store without raising suspension just tell them u just got a tig machine and need a bottle

Nitrogen and Helium are better than Argon for CTB purposes due to their higher weight difference with CO₂ (better CO₂ purging performance), that's why Argon is the least used gas for CTBing (even tho is the most available of all of the inert gases).​

 

[Eleanor]

Helium is a fairly light element and if not enough is used or if it isn't sealed enough it can easily escape, hence why nitrogen, a gas with the same density as air, is much more usable.

Used "chambers" (in quotes) to refenence any hardware used, not a real chamber.

Honestly, if anything, I've become more confused. I'm following an approved method and follow every step, I'm just not sure about which helium tanks to buy. You're making it sound like I will likely fail when I use helium...

 

[GasMonkey]

Where are you from?

 

[Eleanor]

Netherlands

 

[GasMonkey]

If I had to build a setup from scratch on EU I'd go for a 5L 200bar Nitrogen cylinder from GD, Nitrogen regulator with integrated flow meter from GD, Rescue hood with a breathing air plug (there are 2 models with this and 1.5m hose), and connect the hood to the regulator using a breathing air coupler.

Rescue hoods are different from EEBD hoods, they are a type of hood that comes with a longer hose with a plug that can be connected directly to a breathing air coupler, so you can put together a completely plug-and-play setup by getting the proper coupler for your regulator.​

 

[AresCohere]

Honestly, if anything, I've become more confused. I'm following an approved method and follow every step, I'm just not sure about which helium tanks to buy. You're making it sound like I will likely fail when I use helium...

Helium can work it's just harder and more finicky than other, heavier gasses. With the right preparation it can still work.

 

[Eleanor]

I appreciatie the responses, but that's not what I'm asking. I'm only asking whether there's someone here who happens to know whether the helium tank I described contains enough helium for this method to be succesful.

 

[GasMonkey]

At 15 LPM yeah, it's enough.
512.9L / 15LPM = 34 minutes.

 

[Eleanor]

At 15 LPM yeah, it's enough.
512.9L / 15LPM = 34 minutes.

Thank you for your reply!

 

[imrantahir1208]

Without hopefully giving out too much information please google the following: 226-CXG-20UZ87. Is this good enough to ctb?

 

[ftm68_99]

If I had to build a setup from scratch on EU I'd go for a 5L 200bar Nitrogen cylinder from GD, Nitrogen regulator with integrated flow meter from GD, Rescue hood with a breathing air plug (there are 2 models with this and 1.5m hose), and connect the hood to the regulator using a breathing air coupler.

Rescue hoods are different from EEBD hoods, they are a type of hood that comes with a longer hose with a plug that can be connected directly to a breathing air coupler, so you can put together a completely plug-and-play setup by getting the proper coupler for your regulator.​

What is GD? Thanks.

 

[Tears in Rain]

What is GD? Thanks.

I was looking into potentially using inert gas, and I was looking at the megathread. That poster, @GasMonkey probably ctb, because I came across a post of theirs from the summer saying he was planning to leave soon. So, I think they're no longer around. They haven't posted on that megathread since the summer.

They were using the initials of where to potentially buy stuff, as you're not allowed put up links here.
I'm guessing it's the place that's mentioned in the inert gas chapter in the Peaceful Pill handbook. You can download the PPeH Essentials from the Resources section:
https://sanctioned-suicide.net/threads/pph-essentials-2022.107973/

I'll upload the inert gas chapter from it below, if you want to just download that chapter.

 

[ftm68_99]

I was looking into potentially using inert gas, and I was looking at the megathread. That poster, @GasMonkey probably ctb, because I came across a post of theirs from the summer saying he was planning to leave soon. So, I think they're no longer around. They haven't posted on that megathread since the summer.

They were using the initials of where to potentially buy stuff, as you're not allowed put up links here.
I'm guessing it's the place that's mentioned in the inert gas chapter in the Peaceful Pill handbook. You can download the PPeH Essentials from the Resources section:
https://sanctioned-suicide.net/threads/pph-essentials-2022.107973/

I'll upload the inert gas chapter from it below, if you want to just download that chapter.

Thanks so much for your generous and informative reply, Tears in Rain. Much appreciated! :)

 

[suffering_mo]

If I had to build a setup from scratch on EU I'd go for a 5L 200bar Nitrogen cylinder from GD, Nitrogen regulator with integrated flow meter from GD, Rescue hood with a breathing air plug (there are 2 models with this and 1.5m hose), and connect the hood to the regulator using a breathing air coupler.

Rescue hoods are different from EEBD hoods, they are a type of hood that comes with a longer hose with a plug that can be connected directly to a breathing air coupler, so you can put together a completely plug-and-play setup by getting the proper coupler for your regulator.​

Anyone know what Rescue Hood he might be referring to here?