It's maybe not entirely fair but, I've found myself envying them- if I'm honest. Not that it's a great solution anyway. As you pointed out, our justice systems are hardly infallible. It's actually horrific to think innocent people are either jailed or executed.
Let's say they're guilty though. They're a serial killer or serial sex offender or child molestor. Then- no- I don't have much sympathy. In fact- I look at them after literally torchuring people sometimes- being led off to be humanely euthanized. And- I think of all the entirely innocent people suffering with chronic and terminal illness- literally begging for a humane release and- they get denied. Plus- their victims. They put them and their families through a literal hell sometimes. How well should they be treated after doing that?
That's not to say I think people who offend should be sadistically punished. Anything needs to be clinical and professional but, it's messed up that ordinary and good people don't get the right to be able to leave humanely too.
Plus- of course they're put in isolation if they are violent towards others! Why should staff or other inmates have to fear everyday for their own safety? Axel Rudakubana- who was convicted of stabbing to death 3 children and attempting to kill 10 others threw boiling water over prison officers. They are known to mix sugar into boiling water in their kettles (prison napalm they call it) to attack others with. But- people will insist it's their human right to have a hot drink. I think those same people should work in the prisons. See how quickly they change their mind after getting a face full of sticky boiling water.
That's not to say they are all like that of course. It's not to say that reform never works. I don't actually know enough about it. But then, some people are genuinely dangerous- surely? Whether it's their fault or not- they are. They shouldn't necessarily be treated badly but then- what kind of deterrent is it to others who may be tempted to act in the same way- if they are pampered?
I always wondered like, what if I could just sit down with any one of those inmates in a nicely furnished room,.maybe a nice meal,.music playing, all dressed in comfortable clothes, and if I could just hear what those inmates had to say, whatever they wanted to say, they could speak freely and I would hear them out and just listen..what would they say? Would they cry? Would they get angry? Would they beg for forgiveness or make threats?
Or would they tell a totally different story, like something that no one has ever heard before that very moment before they were about to die, all because someone finally treated them with respect and gave them a proper chance to, not just speak freely, but FEEL like they CAN speak freely. What would they say?
I think it would depend on the person. Some may be very receptive to being treated kindly- finally and, genuinely reform. Others may be going along with it because it would look good on a parole board. Others may see it as weakness and ungenuine and trample all over it.
I'm sure some people are genuine. Others are manipulative though. They'll play the game, make the right impression to get out and then possibly reoffend. I'm sure that happens.
I wouldn't assume the softly, softly approach always works though. Would you actually want to work for a organisation that (prsssumably) dissuades you from reporting assaults- including sexual assaults? Presumably because they were worried it would tarnish their image: